New Research In
Physical Sciences
Social Sciences
Featured Portals
Articles by Topic
Biological Sciences
Featured Portals
Articles by Topic
 Agricultural Sciences
 Anthropology
 Applied Biological Sciences
 Biochemistry
 Biophysics and Computational Biology
 Cell Biology
 Developmental Biology
 Ecology
 Environmental Sciences
 Evolution
 Genetics
 Immunology and Inflammation
 Medical Sciences
 Microbiology
 Neuroscience
 Pharmacology
 Physiology
 Plant Biology
 Population Biology
 Psychological and Cognitive Sciences
 Sustainability Science
 Systems Biology
DNA knots reveal a chiral organization of DNA in phage capsids

Edited by Charles R. Cantor, Sequenom, Inc., San Diego, CA, and approved May 10, 2005 (received for review December 14, 2004)
Abstract
Icosahedral bacteriophages pack their doublestranded DNA genomes to nearcrystalline density and achieve one of the highest levels of DNA condensation found in nature. Despite numerous studies, some essential properties of the packaging geometry of the DNA inside the phage capsid are still unknown. We present a different approach to the problems of randomness and chirality of the packed DNA. We recently showed that most DNA molecules extracted from bacteriophage P4 are highly knotted because of the cyclization of the linear DNA molecule confined in the phage capsid. Here, we show that these knots provide information about the global arrangement of the DNA inside the capsid. First, we analyze the distribution of the viral DNA knots by highresolution gel electrophoresis. Next, we perform Monte Carlo computer simulations of random knotting for freely jointed polygons confined to spherical volumes. Comparison of the knot distributions obtained by both techniques produces a topological proof of nonrandom packaging of the viral DNA. Moreover, our simulations show that the scarcity of the achiral knot 4_{1} and the predominance of the torus knot 5_{1} over the twist knot 5_{2} observed in the viral distribution of DNA knots cannot be obtained by confinement alone but must include writhe bias in the conformation sampling. These results indicate that the packaging geometry of the DNA inside the viral capsid is writhedirected.
All icosahedral bacteriophages with doublestranded DNA genomes are believed to pack their chromosomes in a similar manner (1). During phage morphogenesis, a procapsid is first assembled, and a linear DNA molecule is actively introduced inside it by the connector complex (2, 3). At the end of this process, the DNA and its associated water molecules fill the entire capsid volume, where DNA reaches concentrations of 800 mg/ml (4). Some animal viruses (5) and lipoDNA complexes used in gene therapy (6) are postulated to hold similar DNA arrangements as those found in bacteriophages.
Although numerous studies have investigated the DNA packing geometry inside phage capsids, some of its properties remain unknown. Biochemical and structural analyses have revealed that DNA is kept in its B form (79) and that there are no specific DNAprotein interactions (10, 11) or correlation between DNA sequences and their spatial location inside the capsid, with the exception of the cos ends in some viruses (12). Many studies have found that regions of the packed DNA form domains of parallel fibers, which in some cases have different orientations, suggesting a certain degree of randomness (8, 9, 13, 14). The above observations have led to the proposal of several longrange organization models for DNA inside phage capsids: the ball of string model (13), the coaxial spooling model (8, 11, 13, 14), the spiralfold model (15), and the folded toroidal model (16). Liquid crystalline models, which take into account properties of DNA at high concentrations and imply less global organization, have also been proposed (9). In this study, we present a different approach to investigating the packaging geometry of DNA inside phage capsids.
The bacteriophage P4 has a linear, doublestranded DNA genome that is 1011.5 kb in length and flanked by 16bp cohesive cos ends (17). It has long been known that extraction of DNA from P4 phage heads results in a large proportion of highly knotted, nicked DNA circles (18, 19). DNA knotting probability is enhanced in P4 derivatives containing genome deletions (20) and in tailless mutants (21). We recently showed that most of these knots are formed by the cyclization of the DNA while it is confined inside the phage capsid (22). Here, we show that these knots capture information about the global arrangement of the packed DNA. By using highresolution gel electrophoresis, we examine the knot distribution of the viral DNA. Next, we perform Monte Carlo computer simulations of random knotting for freely jointed polygons confined to spherical volumes and compare them with the experimental knot distributions. Our results demonstrate that longrange organization of DNA in the viral capsid is not random and indicate that the packing geometry of the DNA is writhedirected.
Materials and Methods
Isolation of Knotted DNA from P4 Phage Particles. Bacteriophage P4 vir1 del22 was prepared as described in ref. 22. Briefly, the phage was amplified in Escherichia coli strain C1895, which is lysogenic for P2 (the helper prophage). Stocks of P4 vir1 del22 were used to infect E. coli C8001, which is lysogenic for P2 amH13. Because gene H encodes part of the P4 phage tail, this strain produced the tailless mutant of P4 vir1 del22. DNA was obtained from phage particles by following the procedure described by Isaksen et al. (21) with minor modifications: After bacterial lysis, phages were precipitated with polyethylene glycol 8000. Phage precipitates were dissolved in phage buffer containing 10 mM MgCl_{2}/10 mM Tris·HCl, pH 7.2/130 mM ammonium acetate. Phage particles were banded by cesium chloride centrifugation in an NVT65 rotor (Beckman) for 14 h at 45,000 rpm. The banded particles were dialyzed against phage buffer and extracted twice with phenol and once with phenol/chloroform to obtain DNA. Phage DNA was dialyzed against TEN buffer (10 mM Tris·HCl, pH 8/1 mM EDTA/100 mM NaCl) and kept at 4°C.
Electrophoretic Analysis of Knotted DNA. Purified DNA was analyzed by twodimensional gel electrophoresis as described by Trigueros et al. (23). Gel slabs of 0.4% agarose concentration that were equilibrated with TBE buffer (100 mM Tris·borate, pH 8.3/2 mM EDTA) were used. In the first dimension, DNA samples were run at 0.8 V/cm for 40 h at room temperature. After a 90° rotation of the gel, a second dimension was run in the same electrophoresis buffer at 3.4 V/cm for 4 h at room temperature. After ethidium bromide staining of DNA and photography, gels were blotted to nylon membranes, and the DNA was radioprobed for phosphorimaging quantification. A marker ladder for twisttype knots was generated by incubating a supercoiled 10kb plasmid with equimolar amounts of T4 topoisomerase II, as described by Wasserman and Cozzarelli (24). After the knotting reaction, supercoils were removed from DNA by limited nicking in a reaction containing 50 mM Tris (pH 7.5), 5 mM MgC1_{2}, 100 pg/ml each DNA and ethidium bromide, and 2 pg/ml DNase I.
Knot Type Probabilities for P4 DNA in Free Solution. The probability that a knot K of n statistical lengths and diameter d is formed in free solution is given by P_{K} (n, d) = P_{k} (n, 0)exp(rd/n), where r depends on the knot type and equals 22 for the knot 3_{1} and 31 for the knot 4_{1} (25). The knotting probability of a 10kb DNA molecule cyclized in free solution is ≈0.03 (25, 26), which implies an effective DNA diameter near 35 Å. Because P3_{1} (34, 0) = 0.06 and P4_{1} (34, 0) = 0.009, then P3_{1} (34, 35) = 0.027 (1/36 times that of the unknot) and P4_{1} (34, 35) = 0.003 (1/323 times of the unknot). These values were used to estimate the fractions of the knot 3_{1} and the knot 4_{1} generated for P4 DNA in free solution.
Monte Carlo Simulations. Algorithms that generate random distributions of equilateral polygons with zero volume and confined to spherical volumes, as well as algorithms that compute the Alexander polynomial (Δ(t)), have been reported previously (22). Each selected knotted polygon was further identified by evaluating its Alexander polynomial at t = 2 and t = 3. Although the Alexander polynomial is an excellent discriminator among knots of low crossing number and its computation is fast, it does not distinguish completely among some knotted chains [for example, composite knots 3_{1}#3_{1} and 3_{1}#4_{1} have polynomials identical to those of prime knots 8_{20} and 8_{21}, respectively (27)]. Evaluation of the polynomial at t = 2 and t = 3 is also ambiguous because the Alexander polynomial is defined up to units in Z[t ^{1}, t] (28), and therefore the algorithm returns (±n ^{±m}Δ(n)), where n = 2 or 3 and m is an integer. To deal with this uncertainty, we followed van Rensburg and Whittington (27) and chose the largest exponent k such that the product (±n ^{±m}Δ(n))n ^{±k} is an odd integer with n = 2 or 3. This value was taken as the invariant. To compute the writhe, we generated >300 regular projections and diagrams for each selected polygon. To each of the projected crossings a +1 or 1 was assigned by the righthand convention. The directional writhe for each diagram was computed by summing these values. The writhe was then determined by averaging the directional writhe over all possible projections (29). Computer programs were tested by comparing the results with those previously reported (30). To generate writhedirected random distributions of polygons, we used a rejection method in which polygons whose writhe was below a positive value were not sampled.
Results and Discussion
Knot Complexity of DNA Molecules Extracted from Phage P4. We extracted the 10kb DNA from the tailless mutant of phage P4 vir1 del22, which produces 95% knotted molecules (22), and analyzed it by a highresolution twodimensional gel electrophoresis (23) (Fig. 1A ). This technique allowed us to separate DNA knot populations according to their crossing number (i.e., the minimal number of crossings over all projections of a knot), as well as to separate some knot populations of the same crossing number (31, 32). In the first dimension (at low voltage), individual gel bands corresponding to knot populations having crossing numbers between three and nine were discernible; knots with higher crossing numbers were embedded in a long tail (denoted as K in Fig. 1 A ). The second dimension (at high voltage) further resolved individual gel bands corresponding to knot populations with crossing numbers between six and nine. Although knot populations containing three, four, and five crossings (denoted as 35 in Fig. 1B ) migrated as single bands in a main arch of low gel velocity, knot populations containing six and more crossings split into two subpopulations (denoted as 69 and 6′9′ in Fig. 1B ), creating a second arch of greater gel velocity.
We quantified the individual knot populations of three to nine crossings, which represented 2.2% of the total amount of knotted molecules (Fig. 1C ). Densitometer readings confirmed the apparent scarcity of the knot of four crossings (knot 4_{1}) relative to the other knot populations in the main arch of the gel (denoted by 4 in Fig. 1B ). It also made evident the shortage of the knot subpopulation of seven crossings in the second arch of the gel (denoted by 7′ in Fig. 1B ). The scarcity of the knot 4_{1} relative to the knot of three crossings (knot 3_{1}) and to other knot populations is enhanced if we make the correction for DNA molecules plausibly knotted outside the viral capsid. Namely, if a fraction of the observed knots is formed by random cyclization of DNA outside the capsid, then, in the worst case scenario, all observed unknotted molecules (no more than 5% of the total molecules extracted) will be formed in free solution. In such a case, one can predict that 38% of the total number of observed 3_{1} knots and 75% of the observed 4_{1} knots are formed by random knotting in free solution (25, 26). If all of the knots plausibly formed outside the capsid are removed from the observed knot distribution, the experimental values for knots 4_{1} and 3_{1} (1:18 ratio) would be corrected, resulting in a 1:44 ratio.
Identification of Specific Knot Types by Their Location on the Gel. Gel electrophoresis can distinguish some knot types with the same crossing number. For example, at low voltage, torus knots (such as 5_{1} and 7_{1}) migrate slightly slower than their corresponding twist knots (5_{2} and 7_{2}) (31, 32). We used this knowledge in conjunction with a marker ladder for twist knots (3_{1}, 4_{1}, 5_{2}, 6_{1}, and 7_{2}) to identify several gel bands of the phage DNA matching the migration of known knot types (Fig. 2). In the main arch of the gel, in addition to the unambiguous knots 3_{1} and 4_{1}, the knot population of five crossings matched the migration of the torus knot 5_{1}. The other possible fivecrossing knot, the twist knot 5_{2} that migrates between and equidistant to the four and sixcrossing knot populations, appeared to be negligible or absent. The knot population of seven crossings matched the migration of the torus knot 7_{1} rather than the twist knot 7_{2}, which has slightly higher gel velocity. Yet, we cannot identify this gel band as the knot 7_{1}, because other possible knot types of seven crossings cannot be excluded.
Several indicators led us to believe that the second arch of the gel consists of mainly composite knots (resulting from combinations of prime knots). First, the arch starts at knot populations containing six crossings, and no composite knots of fewer than six crossings exist. Second, the population of six crossings matched the migration at low voltage of the granny knot (composite of a 3_{1} plus a 3_{1}, indicated as 3_{1}#3_{1}) (33), although the square knot (the other possible composite of six crossings, 3_{1}#3_{1}) cannot be excluded. Third, consistent with the low amount of 4_{1} knots, the size of the sevencrossing subpopulation is also reduced; thus, any composite sevencrossing knot is 3_{1}#4_{1} (or 3_{1}#4_{1}). The increased gel velocity at high voltage (second gel dimension) of composite knots relative to prime knots of the same crossing number likely reflects distinct flexibility properties of the composites during electrophoresis.
Monte Carlo Simulations of Random Knot Distributions in Confined Volumes. Next, we asked whether the observed distribution of DNA knots could be compatible with a random embedding of the DNA inside the phage capsid. We used Monte Carlo simulations to model knotting of randomly embedded, freely jointed polygons confined to spherical volumes. Because the persistence length of the duplex DNA is not applicable in confined volumes (it is applicable in unbounded threedimensional space), we considered freely jointed polygons as the zeroth approximation of the packed DNA molecule. Then, the flexibility of the chain is given by the ratio R/N, where N is the number of edges in the polygon and R is the sphere radius in edgelength units. When we computed random knot distributions for a range of chain lengths confined to spheres with a fixed radius, the probabilities of the knots 3_{1}, 4_{1}, 5_{1}, and 5_{2} produced nonintersecting distributions, with simpler knots being more probable (Fig. 3A ). That is, the knot 3_{1} is more probable than the knot 4_{1}, and both are more probable than any fivecrossing knot. In addition, the probability of the twist knot 5_{2} is higher than that of the torus knot 5_{1}. Similar results had been observed for other random polymer models with/without volume exclusion and with/without confinement (3438), indicating that this phenomenon is modelindependent. All of the simulated distributions, showing the monotonically decreasing amounts of knotted products with increasing crossing number, highly contrasted with our experimental distribution, in which the probability of the knot 4_{1} is markedly reduced and in which the knot probability of the knot 5_{1} prevails over that of the knot 5_{2} (Fig. 3B ). These differences provide a compelling proof that the embedding of the DNA molecule inside the phage capsid is not random.
Monte Carlo Simulations of WritheDirected Knot Distributions in Confined Volumes. How can we explain the scarcity of 4_{1} in the spectrum of viral knots? The knot 4_{1} is achiral (equivalent to its mirror image). Random polygonal realizations of the 4_{1} knot in free space and in confined volumes produce a family of polygons whose writhe distribution for any polygonal length is a Gaussian curve with zero mean (the writhe is a geometrical quantity measuring the signed spatial deviation from planarity of a closed curve) and whose variance grows as the square root of the length (29). Therefore, we argue that the main reason for the scarcity of the knot 4_{1} is a writhe bias imposed on the DNA inside the phage capsid. To test this hypothesis, we simulated polygons randomly embedded in spheres whose mean writhe value was gradually increased. To induce writhe in the sampling, we used a rejection method in which polygons of writhe below a cutoff value were not sampled. Then, we calculated the probabilities of the prime knots 4_{1}, 5_{1}, and 5_{2} for each writhebiased sampling. The results shown in Fig. 4 were computed with a freely jointed chain of 90 edges confined in a sphere of radius of 4 edgelength units. A drop of the probability of the knot 4_{1}, as well as an exponential increase of the probability of the knot 5_{1} but not of the knot 5_{2}, readily emerged by increasing the writhe rejection value. The same results, but with knots of opposite sign, were obtained for knot distributions with the corresponding negative writhe values. These writheinduced changes in the knot probability distribution are independent of the number of edges in the equilateral polygon and the sphere radius length. Accordingly, previous studies had shown that the mean writhe value of random conformations of a given knot does not depend on the length of the chain but only on the knot type and that these values are modelindependent (3942). Because the writhedirected simulated distributions approach the observed experimental spectrum of knots, we conclude that a high writhe of the DNA inside the phage is the most likely factor responsible for the observed experimental knot spectrum.
Consistent with the involvement of writhe in the DNA packing geometry, it is also the reduced amount of prime knots of six crossings visible in the main arch of the gels (Fig. 1C ). All prime knots of six crossings have a lower mean writhe value Wr (Wr of 6_{1} = 1.23, Wr of 6_{2} = 2.70, and Wr of 6_{3} = 0.16) than the torus knots of five and seven crossings (Wr of 5_{1} = 6.26 and Wr of 7_{1} = 9.15). In contrast, the negligible amount of the twist knot of five crossings (Wr of 5_{2} = 4.54) in the experimental distributions is striking. The apparent predominance of torus knots (5_{1} and 7_{1}) over twist knots (5_{2} and 7_{2}) in the experimental distribution suggests that writhe emerges from a toroidal or spoollike conformation of the packed DNA. Consistent with our findings, theoretical calculations of longrange organization of DNA by Monte Carlo (43) and molecular dynamics methods (4447) favor toroidal and spoollike arrangements for DNA packed inside the phage capsids. Calculations of optimal spoollike conformations of DNA in phage P4 already predicted a large nonzero writhe (45). These studies gave an estimated writhe of 45 for the 10kb DNA, which closely corresponds with the level of supercoiling density typically found in bacterial chromosomes (45).
The actual writhe value of the DNA packaged in the phage P4 capsid cannot be estimated in the present study. The phage P4 capsid has a diameter of 38 nm. If the parameters used to compute writhebiased ensembles as in Fig. 4 (n = 90 and R = 4) were applied to a 10kb DNA molecule, they would translate into 90 segments of 35 nm confined in a model capsid of radius 140 nm. Likewise, our study cannot argue for or against recent models that suggest that to minimize DNA bending energy, a spool conformation might be concentric rather than coaxial (47). Therefore, beyond the main conclusion of this work that the distribution of viral knots requires the mean writhe of the confined DNA be nonzero, the applicability of our simulations to other aspects of the DNA packaging in phage P4 is limited. We argue that further identification of the knotted DNA populations will provide more critical information for the packing geometry of DNA inside the phage.
Conclusions
Knots can be seen as discrete measuring units of the organizational complexity of filaments and fibers. Here, we show that knot distributions of DNA molecules can provide information on the longrange organization of DNA in a biological structure. We chose the problem of DNA packing in an icosahedral phage capsid and addressed the questions of randomness and chirality by comparing experimental knot distributions with simulated knot distributions. The scarcity of the achiral knot 4_{1} and the predominance of the torus knot 5_{1} in the experimental distribution highly contrasted with simulated distributions of random knots in confined volumes, in which the knot 4_{1} is more probable than any fivecrossing knot, and the knot 5_{2} is more probable the knot 5_{1}. To our knowledge, these results produce the first topological proof of nonrandom packaging of DNA inside a phage capsid. Our simulations also show that a reduction of the knot 4_{1} cannot be obtained by confinement alone but must include writhe bias in the conformation sampling. Moreover, in contrast to the knot 5_{2}, the probability of the torus knot 5_{1} rapidly increases in a writhebiased sampling. Given that there is no evidence for any other biological factor that could introduce all of the above deviations from randomness, we conclude that a high writhe of the DNA inside the phage capsid is responsible for the observed knot spectrum and that the cyclization reaction captures that information.
Acknowledgments
We thank R. Calendar (University of California, Berkeley) for providing material for preparing P4 phages and A. Stasiak, S. Harvey, J. C. Wang, and N. Cozzarelli for helpful discussions and comments on the manuscript. This work was supported by grants from the Ministerio Español de Ciencia y Tecnología (BMC200203275), the National Institutes of Health (GM6842301), and the National Science Foundation (DMS9971169) and by a Burroughs Wellcome Fund Interfaces grant to the Program in Mathematics and Molecular Biology.
Footnotes

↵ ** To whom correspondence should be addressed. Email: jrbbmc{at}cid.csic.es.

↵ ‡ Present address: Department of Mathematics and Center for Computation in the Life Sciences, San Francisco State University, San Francisco, CA 94132.

Author contributions: D.W.S. and J.R. designed research; J.A. and J.R. performed research; J.A., M.V., P.M., S.T., and J.R. contributed new reagents/analytic tools; J.A., M.V., P.M., and J.R. analyzed data; and D.W.S. and J.R. wrote the paper.

This paper was submitted directly (Track II) to the PNAS office.
 Copyright © 2005, The National Academy of Sciences
References
 ↵
 ↵
 ↵

↵
Kellenberger, E., Carlemalm, E., Sechaud, J., Ryter, A. & Haller, G. (1986) in Bacterial Chromatin, eds. Gualerzi, C. & Pon, C. L. (Springer, Berlin), p. 11.
 ↵

↵
Schmutz, M., Durand, D., Debin, A., Palvadeau, Y., Eitienne, E. R. & Thierry, A. R. (1999) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 96 , 1229312298. pmid:10535915
 ↵
 ↵
 ↵
 ↵
 ↵
 ↵
 ↵
 ↵

↵
Black, L., Newcomb, W., Boring, J. & Brown, J. (1985) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 82 , 79607964. pmid:3865208
 ↵
 ↵

↵
Liu, L. F., Davis, J. L. & Calendar, R. (1981) Nucleic Acids Res. 9 , 39793989. pmid:6272191

↵
Liu, L. F., Perkocha, L., Calendar, R. & Wang, J. C. (1981) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 78 , 54985502. pmid:6272306

↵
Wolfson, J. S., McHugh, G. L., Hooper, D. C. & Swartz, M. N. (1985) Nucleic Acids Res. 13 , 66956702. pmid:3903657
 ↵

↵
Arsuaga, J., Vazquez, M., Tigueros, S., Sumners, D. W. & Roca, J. (2002) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 99 , 53735377. pmid:11959991
 ↵

↵
Wasserman, S. & Cozzarelli, N. R. (1991) J. Biol. Chem. 266 , 2056720573. pmid:1657929

↵
Rybenkov, V. V., Cozzarelli, N. R. & Vologodskii, A. V. (1993) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 90 , 50375311.

↵
Shaw, Y. S. & Wang, J. C. (1993) Science 260 , 533536. pmid:8475384
 ↵

↵
Murasugi, K. (1996) in Knot Theory and Its Applications (Birkhauser, Boston), pp. 104122.
 ↵
 ↵
 ↵
 ↵
 ↵
 ↵

Millet, K. C. (1998) in Series on Knots and Everything, eds. Gordon, C., Jones, V. F. R., Kauffman, L., Lambropoulou, S. & Przytycki, J. H. (World Scientific, Singapore), Vol. 24, pp. 300358.

Grossberg, A. (1999) in Series on Knots and Everything, eds. Stasiak, A., Katritch, V. & Kauffman, L. H. (World Scientific, Singapore), Vol. 19, pp. 147181.
 ↵
 ↵

Podtelezhnikov, A. A., Cozzarelli, N. R. & Vologodskii, A. V. (1999) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 96 , 1297412979. pmid:10557257

van Rensburg, J., Sumners, D. W. & Whittington, S. G. (1999) in Series on Knots and Everything, eds. Stasiak, A., Katritch, V. & Kauffman, L. H. (World Scientific, Singapore), Vol. 19, pp. 103146.

↵
Cerf, C. & Stasiak, A. (2000) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 97 , 37953798. pmid:10760252
 ↵
 ↵
 ↵
 ↵
Citation Manager Formats
Sign up for Article Alerts
Jump to section
You May Also be Interested in
More Articles of This Classification
Biological Sciences
Related Content
 No related articles found.
Cited by...
 Dynamics of supercoiled DNA with complex knots: largescale rearrangements and persistent multistrand interlocking
 Pore translocation of knotted DNA rings
 Topological patterns in twodimensional gel electrophoresis of DNA knots
 Absence of knots in known RNA structures
 How molecular knots can pass through each other
 Topological friction strongly affects viral DNA ejection
 Visualization of uncorrelated, tandem symmetry mismatches in the internal genome packaging apparatus of bacteriophage T7
 Influence of chain stiffness on knottedness in single polymers
 New biologically motivated knot table
 DNADNA interactions in bacteriophage capsids are responsible for the observed DNA knotting
 Ionic effects on viral DNA packaging and portal motor function in bacteriophage {varphi}29