The process presents big legal, logistical, ethical, political, financial, and architectural challenges.
Image credit: Shutterstock/Andy Levin.
New Research In
Physical Sciences
Featured Portals
Articles by Topic
Biological Sciences
Featured Portals
Articles by Topic
-
Contributed by Pierre Chambon, December 21, 2007 (received for review October 7, 2007)
Abstract
Estrogen signaling is mediated by estrogen receptors α (ERα) and β (ERβ). Although a consensus has now been reached concerning many physiological functions of ERα, those of ERβ are still controversial: When housed and examined in two distant laboratories, mice originating from the same initial ERβ mutant exhibited widely different phenotypes, which were themselves different from the phenotype of another ERβ mutant previously generated in our laboratory. Because, in addition to a knockout insertion in exon 3, all these mouse mutants displayed alternative splicing transcripts, we have now constructed a ERβ mouse mutant (ERβST L−/L−) in which exon 3 was cleanly deleted by Cre/LoxP-mediated excision and was devoid of any transcript downstream of exon 3. Both females and males were sterile. The histology of the ovary was mildly affected, and no histological defects were detected in other organs, neither in females nor in males. Our present results, which are in contrast with previously published data, suggest that, with the notable exception of male and female reproduction, ERβ is not required in the mouse for the development and homeostasis of the major body systems.
Estrogens have well acknowledged functions in ovary, testis, and male and female reproductive tracts (1–4) that are mediated through the nuclear receptors isotypes estrogen receptors α (ERα) (5, 6) and β (ERβ) (7–9). In addition, numerous clinical and animal model studies have pointed to estrogen functions in bone, adipose tissue, brain, and immune and cardiovascular systems and have suggested the potential usefulness of estrogen receptor modulators in the prevention and/or clinical management of osteoporosis, obesity, breast cancers, and neurodegenerative and autoimmune diseases (2–4, 10, 11).
Although a consensus has been reached concerning many physiological functions of ERα, those of ERβ are still controversial (12). To date, several genetically engineered mice aimed at functionally ablating the ERβ gene have been generated and analyzed in different laboratories. Krege et al. (13) disrupted the mouse ERβ gene (ERβKOCH) (see ref. 12 for ERβ mutant nomenclature) by inserting a neo cassette in the 3′ to 5′ orientation into PstI site of exon 3, which encodes the first zinc finger of the DNA-binding domain (DBD). The full-length ERβ mRNA was not detected in the mutant mouse, which, nevertheless, expressed several transcript variants where exon 3 was consistently spliced out. The ERβKOCH mouse colony was subsequently duplicated and transferred to Karolinska Institute (ERβKOKI). Dupont et al. (14) generated an independent ERβ mutant mouse line by inserting the neo cassette in the 5′ to 3′ orientation into the SpI site of the exon 3 (ERβKOST). As in the case of ERβKOCH, several splice variants lacking exon 3 were detected in this mutant. Moreover, Shughrue et al. (15) reported the disruption of the ERβ gene by insertion of stop codons in all three reading frames and of a neo cassette in intron 1. This strategy resulted in the truncation of exons 1 and 2 encoding the A/B domain and the N-terminal half of the DBD and in a deletion of intron 1 (ERβKOWY).
Morphological analysis of ERβKOCH mutant line revealed a hyperplasia of prostatic epithelium (13), whereas examination of ERβKOKI mutant line (16) indicated the presence of prostatic intraepithelial hyperplasia (PIN). In addition, examination of the ERβKOKI line supported an involvement of ERβ in the development and/or maintenance of several neuronal populations of the brain (17, 18). However, lesions reported in the ventral prostate of ERβKOCH and ERβKOKI males were not found in the ERβKOST line (14). Because a low frequency of prostate lesions in old ERβKOST males might have been overlooked due to the small number of samples analyzed (14), we subsequently examined a larger group (n > 15) of 20-month-old ERβKOST males for possible prostate lesions (our unpublished results). In the same study, we also characterized the status of the brain in ERβKOST males. Unexpectedly, we found that prostates and brains of ERβKOST mice, in contrast to their counterparts in ERβKOKI mice, were indistinguishable from those of our WT littermates (our unpublished results).
In all of the above disruptions of the ERβ gene several transcript variants were found, encoding putative truncated peptides lacking the DBD and ligand binding domain (13–15) or the DBD only (13). To eliminate any possible phenotypic effect of these transcript variants, we decided to generate an ERβ-null mutant, hereafter referred to as ERβST L−/L−, in which exon 3 was deleted through Cre/LoxP-mediated excision and which was devoid of any transcript downstream of exon 3. We report here the characterization of these ERβST L−/L− mutants, which do not display morphological defects in the prostate, in contrast to ERβKOCH and ERβKOKI mutants (13, 16, 19), or, in contrast to ERβKOKI mutants, defects in the brain (17), lymphoid tissues (20), heart (21), lung (22, 23), colon (24), and urinary bladder (25).
Results and Discussion
Generation of a ERβ-Null Mouse (ERβSTL−/L−), Characterization of Its Reproductive Function, and General Pathophysiological Analysis.
To generate a fully disrupted ERβ mutant, we used the Cre/loxP strategy. Chimeric males derived from mutant ES clones transmitted the mutation through their germ line. We identified mice in which all of the sequences located between the loxP sites flanking ERβ exon 3 were excised (L-allele) [supporting information (SI) Fig. 5a and SI Materials and Methods ].
The inactivation of the ERβ gene was first indicated by the absence of ERβ protein in prostate and testis of homozygous ERβL−/L− mice (SI Fig. 5b and SI Materials and Methods ). The characterization of the ERβ transcripts by RT-PCR, using total RNAs extracted from uterus (SI Fig. 5c ) and ovaries (data not shown) of WT, ERβ+/L− and ERβL−/L− mice unambiguously confirmed that the ERβ mutation was a null mutation, because all of the expected reverse transcription products of ERβ mRNA were obtained with WT (+/+) and ERβ+/L− RNAs, whereas no transcript downstream exon 3 could be detected in ERβL−/L− mice, hereafter called ERβST L−/L− mutants (SI Fig. 5c , SI Materials and Methods , and data not shown).
Five-month-old (hereafter referred to as “young”) and 16- to 19-month-old (hereafter referred to as “old”) ERβL−/L− mutants and their wild-type (WT) male and female littermates were subjected to systematic biochemical, hematological, macroscopical, and histopathological analyses. Biochemical and hematological parameters were determined in old mice.
Young and old ERβL−/L− and WT mice displayed no statistically significant differences with respect to body and organ weights (SI Fig. 6) and, with the exception of ovaries, ERβST L−/L− organs appeared normal on histological sections stained with hematoxylin and eosin (SI Table 1, below, and data not shown). An extensive clinical chemistry and hematological examination did not reveal relevant differences between the ERβST L−/L− and WT mice (SI Fig. 7). Additional investigations were nevertheless performed on organs, which, in ERβKOKI mice, displayed histological defects, either already in young adults, i.e., mammary glands, colon, and urinary bladder, or at advanced ages, i.e., brain, prostate, bone marrow, spleen, heart, and lung (for references, see Introduction).
Sterility and Reproductive System in ERβSTL−/L− Mutant Mice.
ERβST L−/L− females/males were continuously mated with fertile males/females. Because no vaginal plugs were observed in fertile females after mating with ERβST L−/L− males and as no pregnancy was produced in ERβST L−/L− females by fertile males, we concluded that both females and males mutants are sterile. Testis and epididymis histology of ERβL−/L− males were normal, and their spermatozoa appeared normally mobile (data not shown).
To determine whether an ovulation defect could cause the infertility in female mutants, we performed superovulation experiments, using ERβST L−/L− and WT females. No oocytes were found in any of the mutant females tested (n = 19), compared with a mean number of 46 oocytes per WT female (n = 8). Histological examination of ovaries from 5-month-old ERβST L−/L− females revealed the presence of (i) follicles at various stages of development, ranging from primordial to large antral; (ii) rare (i.e., mean of 0.5 corpora lutea per ovary in ERβST L−/L− mutants versus 2.5 corpora lutea per ovary in WT mice; n = 5), but morphologically normal corpora lutea (SI Fig. 8 a and b ); (iii) morphologically normal thecal cell layer (SI Fig. 8 c–f ); (iv) a higher amount of stromal collagen compared with age-matched WT mice (SI Fig. 8 g and h ); and (v) an increased number of atretic follicles (i.e., mean of 2.4 atretic follicles per ovary in ERβST L−/L− mutants versus 1.25 atretic follicles per ovary in WT mice; n = 5) (data not shown). Uterus histology of ERβST L−/L− females was normal (data not shown). The reduced number of corpora lutea is in accordance with data obtained on ERβKOCH (13) and ERβKOST mutants (14), and an increased follicle atresia was also detected in ERβKOCH mutants (13). However, ERβST L−/L− mutants do not display the increased collagen deposits and decreased vascularization of the theca layer reported in ERβKOKI ovaries (26).
The ovarian cycle of virgin 8-month-old ERβST L−/L− mice and of their WT littermates (n = 4 for each genotype) was assessed daily from the vaginal smear aspect and staged according to (27) in proestrus, estrus, metestrus I, metestrus II, and diestrus stages (SI Fig. 9 and data not shown) over a 24-day period. In two of the 8-month-old ERβST L−/L− mice the ovarian cycle was irregular, varying between 6 and 10 days, and no proestrus, estrus, and metestrus I stages were ever detected (SI Fig. 9 d–f ). These three stages were replaced by a single abnormal stage in which the vaginal smear contained mainly nonnucleated epithelial cells intermingled with nucleated epithelial cells and polymorphonuclear neutrophils (SI Fig. 9d ). The two other ERβST L−/L− mice had no ovarian cycling activity and displayed only the abnormal vaginal smear (SI Fig. 9d ). Thus, even though the histology of ERβST L−/L− ovaries appears mildly affected, their function is impaired.
The morphology of mammary glands from 5- and 8-month-old ERβST L−/L− (SI Fig. 10 d and e ) females was examined. At both ages the aspect of the ERβST L−/L− mammary gland was identical with that of a metestrus WT mammary gland, which exhibit a ductal system without terminal end buds and alveolar buds (SI Fig. 10 a, b, d, and e and ref. 28). It seems that, in the absence of a normal ovarian cycle (see above), ERβST L−/L− females can establish the normal ductal system seen in WT metestrus but fail to generate the progesterone-induced side branching seen in WT diestrus (SI Fig. 10c and ref. 28). We also looked for possible age-related pathological modifications (29) and found that mammary glands from 19-month-old ERβST L−/L− females were indistinguishable from those of age-matched WT littermates and, in particular, that there was no cystic dilatation of ductal structures (SI Fig. 10 f–i ).
In contrast to our results, Couse and Korach (1) have reported that ductal structure of glands from virgin ERβKOCH females and differentiation of lactating glands are both normal, whereas Förster et al. (30) reported normal ductal development but impaired side branching and alveolar development in glands from virgin and lactating ERβKOKI females, respectively. Furthermore, Palmieri et al. (29) described an age-related “severe cystic breast disease,” which is in contrast to our data showing normal histological aspect of the mammary glands in old ERβST L−/L− females.
Normal Morphology, Cell Proliferation, and Apoptosis in ERβSTL−/L− Prostates.
The mouse prostate is composed of three paired lobes: anterior prostate, ventral prostate, and dorsolateral prostate lobes (31). Ventral prostate lobes of 5- and 16-month-old ERβST L−/L− and WT males contained two types of secretory units (called prostate alveoli): (i) alveoli lined by a low-cuboidal to flattened epithelium displaying few folds (Fig. 1 a and b) and (ii) “functionally hyperplastic” alveoli lined by a columnar and extensively folded epithelium (Fig. 1 a–d and ref. 31). Examination of three sections containing ventral, dorsal, and anterior prostate samples from 5-month-old ERβST L−/L− (n = 3) prostate did not reveal histological anomalies. Serially sectioned prostates from four 16-month-old ERβST L−/L− and four age-matched WT mice were then examined. In these mice, various atypical (i.e., karyomegaly and hyperchromatic) nuclei were present either in quiescent alveoli or in functionally hyperplastic alveoli with the same low frequency in ERβST L−/L− and WT ventral (SI Fig. 11 a–f and h ) and dorsolateral prostate lobes (SI Fig. 11g ). With respect to cytoplasmic atypia, the incidence of epithelial cells vacuolization was significantly lower in the ventral prostate of ERβST L−/L−mutants, but the physiological significance of this vacuolization, if any, is unknown. A single case of true epithelial hyperplasia (i.e., a papillary outgrowth of the epithelium; ref. 32) was detected in a WT male out of four (SI Fig. 11 e, f, and h ). Thus, the histological aspect of the ventral prostate epithelium of the 16-month-old ERβST L−/L− analyzed on serial histological sections was essentially similar to its counterpart in aged-matched WT males. Likewise, histological analysis of 16-month-old ERβST L−/L− dorsolateral and anterior prostate lobes failed to reveal differences with their counterparts in WT males. The absence of specific histological lesions in ventral prostate of 16-month-old ERβST L−/L− mutants is in sharp contrast with defects reported in the ERβKOKI ventral prostatic epithelium, which displays multiple hyperplastic foci, readily visible at 5 months, and affecting 80% of mutants by 12 months of age (13, 16, 33).
Fig. 1.
Normal morphology and cell proliferation in the ventral prostate of 16-month-old ERβST L−/L− mice. (a–d) Hematoxylin and eosin-stained sections of ventral prostate. (c and d) Higher magnification of functionally hyperplastic alveoli. (e–h) Immunostaining for detection of the cell proliferation marker Ki67 in ventral prostate. Arrows point to Ki67-positive epithelial cells (red signals). (g and h) Enlargement of the black frames from e and f, respectively. E, prostatic epithelium; M, smooth muscle; VP1 and VP2, alveoli without and with functional hyperplasia, respectively. Four males of each genotype were used in each type of assay. (Scale bar: a and b, 500 μm; c–f, 50 μm.)
To further assess epithelial homeostasis in ventral and dorsolateral prostate lobes of 16-month-old ERβST L−/L− mutants, we investigated cell proliferation and apoptosis through immunohistochemical detection of the proliferation marker Ki67 and TUNEL assays, respectively (n = 4). Ki67-positive cells were rare and proliferation indices (i.e., ratios between Ki67-positive nuclei and total number of nuclei stained with DAPI) were not significantly different between ERβST L−/L− and WT prostate epithelia (Fig. 1 e–h and SI Fig. 11i ). These observations are consistent with previous reports showing very low proliferation rates in the WT mouse prostate (14, 34) and in its ERβKOST counterpart (ref. 14 and data not shown). However, they are in sharp contrast with results from ref. 19, showing that most epithelial cells in ventral prostate lobes of 12-month-old ERβKOKI males stain positively for Ki67. We also explored apoptosis in ventral and dorsal prostates of 16-month-old ERβST L−/L− and WT mice. No apoptotic epithelial cell was detected on the sections analyzed (data not shown). We conclude that there are no differences between 16-month-old ERβST L−/L− and WT males with respect to prostate morphology, proliferation indices and apoptosis of epithelial cells.
The Brain of 16-Month-Old ERβSTL−/L− Mutant Males Is Morphologically Normal.
The analysis was focused on the somatosensory cortex of 16-month-old ERβST L−/L− mutant males, because severe alterations of this structure were recorded in aging ERβKOKI males (17). In old ERβST L−/L− males (n = 5), the thickness of the somatosensory cortex was normal (Fig. 2 a and b), and five layers, differing in neuron morphology, were clearly identified, namely the molecular (I), small pyramidal (II + III), granular (IV), large pyramidal (V), and polymorphic (VI) cell layers (Fig. 2 c and d and data not shown), which were indistinguishable from their counterparts in aged-matched WT males. Somatosensory cortex neurons that were identified as cells displaying a large nucleus containing finely dispersed chromatin and a prominent nucleolus (35) were counted. No difference could be found between ERβST L−/L− and WT males in any of the five layers (SI Fig. 12b ). In addition, glial fibrillary acidic protein (GFAP) staining of brain sections did not reveal significant differences in the number of glial cells between mutant and WT brain regions, including the paraventricular nucleus of the hypothalamus (compare Fig. 2 e with Fig. 2 f), medial amygdala (compare Fig. 2 g with Fig. 2 h), and medial preoptic nucleus (data not shown). Moreover, no significant difference in cerebral hemisphere weight was detected between old ERβST L−/L− and WT males and females (n = 7) (SI Fig. 12a ). Similar results were obtained in ERβKOST mutants (data not shown).
Fig. 2.
The ERβST L−/L− mutation does not alter architecture and neuronal density of the somatosensory cortex and does not elicit astrocytosis in 16-month-old mice. (a–d) Coronal sections at similar levels of the brains of WT and ERβST L−/L− males. (e–h) Immunodetection of GFAP (red signals) and DAPI counterstain (blue nuclei) in the paraventricular nucleus (e and f) and amygdala (g and h). C, cerebral cortex. Five males of each genotype were used for histology. (Scale bar: a and b, 500 μm; c and d, 250 μm; e–h, 30 μm.)
Wang et al. (17) described the ERβKOKI somatosensory cortex: “the overall structure is disorganized with no clear evidence of layers II, III, IV and V”. In addition, the ERβKOKI brain exhibits neuronal hypocellularity in the same cortical layers, and astrogliosis in the medial preoptic area, paraventricular nucleus of hypothalamus and medial amygdala nucleus in 2-month-old mutants (17); moreover, by 2 years of age, the ERβKOKI brain appeared grossly atrophic (17). Clearly, the disorganization of cortical architecture, hypocellularity of cerebral cortex, astrocytosis, and brain atrophy that have been reported to be hallmarks of the ERβKOKI mutant phenotype are all lacking in our present ERβST L−/L− mutants and in our previous ERβKOST mutants (ref. 14 and data not shown).
Lymphoid Organs of 16- to 19-Month-Old ERβSTL−/L− Mutants Appear Normal.
Mean spleen weights were not significantly different in old ERβST L−/L− mutant and in WT males and females (SI Fig. 6). Histological analysis of these ERβST L−/L− mutants did not reveal any evidence of myeloproliferation in spleen (Fig. 3 a and b) and bone marrow (Fig. 3 c and d), and of myeloid infiltrates in nonhematopoietic organs (n = 9) (e.g., lungs, livers, and kidneys; data not shown). Peripheral blood in ERβST L−/L− mice (n = 10 for males and n = 7 for females) was normal with respect to the total number of white blood cells, and lymphocyte, granulocyte, and monocyte numbers (SI Fig. 7 and SI Fig. 12 c–e ). Likewise, FACS analysis of spleen and bone marrow from 19-month-old ERβST L−/L− females (n = 4) were normal with respect to total cells count and to myelocyte and B-lymphocyte numbers (SI Fig. 12 f and g ).
Fig. 3.
Absence of myeloproliferation in 16- to 19-month-old ERβST L−/L− mice. (a–d) Sections of hematopoietic compartment of the spleen (a and b) and bone marrow (c and d) of ERβST L−/L− females (hematoxylin and eosin). Myeloid precursors (MP) appear as large cells, containing (i) a large, pale-stained nucleus displaying prominent nucleoli and a finely granular chromatin and (ii) a relatively low abundance of lightly stained cytoplasm. In contrast, erythroid precursors (EP) are medium- to small-sized cells, with dark nuclei and low amount of darkly stained cytoplasm. MK, megakaryocyte. Nine mice of each sex and genotype were used for histology. (Scale bar: 8 μm.)
In contrast, ERβKOKI mice were reported to develop by one year of age a marked splenomegaly accompanied by (i) granulocyte infiltration of liver and lung, (ii) an increased number of leukocytes in peripheral blood, and (iii) an increased number of granulocytes in bone marrow (20). We conclude that, in striking contrast to ERβKOKI mutants, ERβST L−/L− mutants do not display hematological abnormalities.
Normal Heart and Lung Morphology in ERβSTL−/L− Mutants.
Lung alveoli of ERβST L−/L− females were carefully examined, because various alterations of these structures were recorded in ERβKOKI females (22, 23). We first compared alveoli of 19-month-old ERβST L−/L− and WT females (n = 10) on histological sections stained with hematoxylin and eosin. No difference in thickness and cellular composition of alveolar walls (comprising endothelial cells and type 1 and 2 pneumocytes) and in the content of alveolar lumens was observed (Fig. 4 a and b). Additionally, upon staining with sirius red, fibrillar collagen deposits were undetectable in alveoli of these old ERβST L−/L− females (n = 4) (SI Fig. 13 a and b ), and morphometric assessment of alveolar surface between ERβST L−/L− and WT females yielded no significant difference (n = 5) (Fig. 4 i). Therefore, the lungs defects reported in ERβKOKI females (22, 23), namely (i) larger and fewer alveoli than in WT females; (ii) large areas of unexpanded alveoli; (iii) increased collagen deposits in alveolar walls; and (iv) by the age of 1 year, surfactant accumulation in alveolar spaces were all absent in ERβST L−/L− females.
Fig. 4.
Normal morphology of the lung and heart of 16- to 19-month-old ERβST L−/L− mice. (a and b) Normal cellular composition of the lung of ERβST L−/L− females (hematoxylin and eosin). (c and d) Normal cardiomyocyte size and intercellular spaces in the heart of ERβST L−/L− males (modified Mallory's trichrome). (e and f) Normal pattern of f-actin distribution in the sarcomeres of ERβST L−/L−hearts; sections are stained with FITC-conjugated phalloidin. (g and h) Normal structure of intercalated discs in ERβST L−/L− hearts; transmission electron microscopy. (i) Normal mean alveolar surface in ERβST L−/L− female lungs (arbitrary units; pixels × 103; means ± SEM). (j) Normal mean left ventricular wall surface in ERβST L−/L− male heart (arbitrary units; pixel × 105; means ± SEM). A, alveolar lumen; CM, cardiomyocytes; E, endothelial cell; I and Z, I and Z bands, respectively; ID, intercalated disk; IS, intercellular spaces; M, mitochondria; P1 and P2, type 1 and 2 pneumocytes, respectively. Nineteen-month-old females of each genotype were used, 10 for histological analysis and 5 for alveolar surface measurement; 16-month-old males of each genotype were used, 8 for evaluation of cardiomyocytes size and left ventricle wall surface, 5 for f-actin staining and 3 for electron microscopy. (Scale bar: a and b, 40 μm; c–f, 100 μm; g and h, 2 μm.)
Heart morphology was investigated in 16-month-old males. No significant differences in heart weight (SI Fig. 6), cardiomyocyte size and intercellular space (Fig. 4 c and d), and left ventricle wall surface (Fig. 4 j) were observed between ERβST L−/L− mutants and their WT littermates (n = 8). It appears, therefore, that 16-month-old ERβST L−/L− males do not exhibit signs of cardiac hypertrophy, in contrast to ERβKOKI males that show enlarged hearts, cardiomyocytes, and intercellular spaces by 8 months of age (21). Phalloidin staining of sarcomere I-bands (Fig. 4 e and f) did not show differences in myofibrils parallelism, and ultrastructural analysis of the left ventricular myocardium did not reveal abnormalities in size and morphology of intercalated discs (Fig. 4 g and h). These observations are in marked contrast with those made with ERβKOKI male hearts, which display irregular orientation of their myofibrils and disrupted intercalated discs (21). The heart of females, which was also reported to exhibit features of hypertrophy in the ERβKOKI mutants (21), was not investigated in our ERβST L−/L− mutants.
The ERβSTL−/L− Urinary Bladder and Colon Display a Normal Structure.
The bladder, proximal, and distal colon of 5-month-old male (n = 6) and female (n = 6) ERβST L−/L− mutants were analyzed on histological sections stained with hematoxylin and eosin. In addition, alcian blue staining was used to visualize acid mucins in intestinal goblet cells (36). No difference was observed with respect to bladder histology (SI Fig. 14 g and h ), colon cells populations (SI Fig. 14 a–d ), and acid mucins distribution (SI Fig. 14 e and f ) between ERβST L−/L− mutants and age-matched WT mice. In contrast, the bladder of females and colon of both sexes of young ERβKOKI have been reported to display defects that correct with aging (24, 25). More specifically, in young female ERβKOKI mice, the bladder was reported to develop features resembling human interstitial cystitis in females (25) and, in both sexes, the colon exhibited severe subepithelial lymphoid infiltrates predominantly in its proximal portion and an abnormal mucin distribution in its distal portion (24). We conclude that the bladder and colon of our ERβST L−/L− mutants lack the morphological abnormalities that were found in young ERβKOKI mutants.
Conclusions
The discovery of ERβ (7–9) has rejuvenated the field of estrogen receptor research (reviewed in refs. 2, 11, and 12). To investigate the physiological functions of this receptor, four groups have independently characterized mutant mouse lines bearing loss-of-function mutations of the ERβ gene, namely the ERβKOCH (13), ERβKOKI (reviewed in ref. 11), ERβKOST (14), and ERβKOWY (15) lines. Even though a perfect match between the phenotypes of ERβ mutant mouse lines was not to be expected, the phenotypic differences between ERβKOCH, ERβKOKI, and ERβKOST are puzzling (12), particularly in the case of ERβKOCH and ERβKOKI, which originate from the same mutant colony. With the hope to uncover, at least partially, the origin of these differences, we generated a fifth mutant mouse line, ERβST L−/L−, by Cre/LoxP-mediated deletion of exon 3 that encodes the first zinc finger of the ERβ DBD. In contrast to the previously generated ERβ mutants, no ERβ transcript of any exons located downstream of exon 3 and no epitope reacting with an antibody directed against the F region of ERβ could be detected in these ERβST L−/L− mutants (see Introduction). Thus, we conclude that the ERβST L−/L− mouse is a genuine null mutant.
We undertook a series of pathophysiological investigations on ERβST L−/L− mice that encompass clinical biochemistry, FACS analyses, necropsy and histology of a number of organs and systems, morphometry, and electron microscopy. We conclude that ERβST L−/L− mice of both sexes are sterile, in contrast to previous reports mentioning hypofertility in females and normal fertility in males in ERβKOCH (13) and ERβKOST lines (14). The origin for the sterility of ERβST L−/L− males is unknown, because their gonads and internal genital organs are histologically normal and the mobility of their spermatozoa appears also normal. It is, however, possible that the epididymis, vas deferens, seminal vesicle, and/or prostate gland, which all express ERβ in WT mice (ref. 37 and references therein) may not be fully functional in ERβST L−/L− males, leading to impairment of sperm function(s) that is (are) critical for fertilization. Alternatively, the absence of ERβ may negatively interfere with male sexual behavior, because, in WT mice, ERβ is expressed in neurons from the medial preoptic area and amygdala (ref. 38 and references therein), which are known to play important roles in male sexual behavior. Along the same lines, it is interesting that ERβKOCH mice display a delay with respect to the age at which the first ejaculation occurs (39), although their sexual behavior appears to be otherwise normal (40, 41). In addition, recent data implicate ERβ in the processes of defeminization of the male brain (42) and potentiation of male aggressive behavior (40).
The ERβST L−/L− female sterility is due to their incapacity to ovulate. The lack of ovulation, resulting in an absence of estrus cycles, impairs mammary gland development. ERβST L−/L− mammary glands correspond to a WT mammary gland blocked at metestrus, in which the ductal system is normally formed, and the alveolar buds are lacking. This is in contrast with mammary glands of ERβKOCH (1, 13) and ERβKOKI (29, 30) mice, which are hypofertile, undergo pregnancy and lactation, and develop alveolar buds.
Our ERβST L−/L− mutant mice do not display abnormalities of the (i) ventral prostate morphology, epithelial proliferation, and apoptosis; (ii) brain morphology and cerebral cortex layers organization, thickness, and cellularity; (iii) heart morphology, morphometry, and ultrastructure; (iv) lung alveolar size and content; (v) goblet cells disposition and mucinous content in the colon; (vi) total and population-specific cellularity of hematopoietic organs; and (vii) urinary bladder histology. In all of these organs and systems, our present observations are in sharp contrast with the extensive alterations reported in ERβKOKI mice prostate (13, 16, 19), brain (17), hematopoietic organs (20), heart (21), lung (22, 23), colon (24), and bladder (25) (see Results and SI Fig. 5–14). However, the normality of the prostate and brain of ERβST L−/L− mice is in accordance with our previous results in ERβKOST mice (ref. 14 and Introduction). Interestingly, the absence of defects in aging prostates has also been mentioned in the case of ERβKOCH mice in review articles (43), but whether the ERβKOCH mutation affects the structure of nonreproductive organs is unknown. To our knowledge, no morphological data concerning ERβKOWY (15) mice are available.
In conclusion, differences in environmental and genetic backgrounds and the presence of different transcript variant, which are particular to each mutant, may possibly account for the relatively minor phenotypic differences displayed by the ERβKOCH, ERβKOST, and ERβST L−/L− mutants (ref. 12 and this article). However, it is more difficult to conceive how such differences could provide a plausible explanation for the highly pleiotropic pathologies displayed by ERβKOKI mutants and the relative scarcity of defects exhibited by our previous (14) and present ERβKO mutants and even more so by the Chapel Hill ERβKOCH mutants. To solve these puzzling discrepancies, mice from Chapel Hill and Strasbourg colonies should be housed at Karolinska Institute, and their phenotype should be assessed at old ages. Reciprocally, young mice from Karolinska Institute colony should be housed in Chapel Hill and Strasbourg husbandries and examined at old ages.
Our present ERβST L2/L2 conditional mutant line provides a useful tool to further dissect the function of ERβ through cell type-/time-specific Cre-mediated ablation.
Materials and Methods
Morphology, Immunohistochemistry, and Morphometry.
For routine histology, organs were dissected, fixed in 4% (wt/vol) buffered formaldehyde, and embedded in paraffin, except testes that were fixed in Bouin's fluid. Slides were analyzed by four independent observers competent in mouse histopathology. Neurons were counted (17). For electron microscopical analyses, myocardium from heart apex was immersion-fixed in 2.5% glutaraldehyde/2.5% paraformaldehyde in 0.1 M sodium cacodylate buffer. Staining of mammary gland in whole-mounts was performed according to the Eumorphia standard operating procedure (http://empress.har.mrc.ac.uk). F-actin was stained by using fluorescent phalloidin. TUNEL assays were performed according to manufacturer instructions (Chemicon International). The proliferation marker Ki67 and the glial fibrillary acidic protein (GFAP) were detected according to standard immunohistochemical procedures (see SI Materials and Methods for details).
Twenty photomicrographs at a ×20 magnification (lung) and one image encompassing the circumference of the left ventricle (sectioned transversally according to ref. 21) were acquired for each mouse. The photomicrographs were converted to black and white bitmap images, using Photoshop. White areas represent surfaces of interest (i.e., total alveolar space or left ventricular wall), which were then measured by using a home-made algorithm. Total alveolar space surface was further divided by the number of alveoli to calculate, in each image, the mean alveolar surface. A CD containing all figures at high resolution is available upon request.
Clinical Chemistry and FACS Analyses.
Blood was collected by intracardiac puncture. Clinical chemistry were performed according to Eumorphia recommendations (http://empress.har.mrc.ac.uk). FACS analyses were performed as described in SI Materials and Methods .
Acknowledgments
We thank Dr. L. M. Garcia-Segura (Consejo Superior de Investigaciones Científicas, Madrid, Spain) and Dr. Jacqueline Trouillas (Institut Fédératif de Recherche 62, Lyon, France) for an expert and a critical comparative examination of histological sections of WT and ERβST L−/L− mice and Dr. Cathrin Brisken (Institut Suisse de Recherche Expérimentale sur le Cancer, Lausanne, Switzerland) and Dr. Heather Harris (Wyeth Research, Collegeville, PA) for a critical reading of the manuscript and suggestions. We acknowledge the technical assistance of Jean-Marie Garnier, Lourdes Ponce-Perez, Thomas Ding, Muriel Klopfenstein, and Fabrice Augé. This work was supported by the European project Estrogen in Women Aging Contract LSHM-CT-2005-518245 and the Association pour la Recherche a l'Institut de Génétique et de Biologie Moleculaire et Cellulaire.
Footnotes
- *To whom correspondence should be addressed. E-mail: chambon{at}titus.u-strasbg.fr
-
Author contributions: A.K. and M.M. designed research; M.C.A., A.K., and M.M. performed research; M.C.A., A.K., P.C., and M.M. analyzed data; and M.C.A., A.K., P.C., and M.M. wrote the paper.
-
The authors declare no conflict of interest.
-
This article contains supporting information online at www.pnas.org/cgi/content/full/0712029105/DC1.
- © 2008 by The National Academy of Sciences of the USA
References
Sterility and absence of histopathological defects in nonreproductive organs of a mouse ERβ-null mutant
Sign up for Article Alerts
Jump to section
You May Also be Interested in
The approach is finding increasing use in scientific and medical fields as a way to explore the possible consequences of technological development.
Image credit: “Ocean back from the Brink” image reproduced with the permission of the Radical Ocean Futures Project, Stockholm Resilience Centre. Copyright, Simon Stålenhag.
Ellen Welti explains how grasshoppers in a Kansas prairie could be in decline even with abundant grass.
Analysis of sedentary behaviors of Hadza hunter-gatherers in Tanzania suggests humans require daily muscle activity from movement and resting postures.
Image credit: David A. Raichlen.
Analysis of resting-state fMRI data from 928 people raises the possibility that dietary interventions might help protect against age-related cognitive decline.
Image credit: Pixabay/sbtlneet.