Skip to main content
  • Submit
  • About
    • Editorial Board
    • PNAS Staff
    • FAQ
    • Accessibility Statement
    • Rights and Permissions
    • Site Map
  • Contact
  • Journal Club
  • Subscribe
    • Subscription Rates
    • Subscriptions FAQ
    • Open Access
    • Recommend PNAS to Your Librarian
  • Log in
  • My Cart

Main menu

  • Home
  • Articles
    • Current
    • Special Feature Articles - Most Recent
    • Special Features
    • Colloquia
    • Collected Articles
    • PNAS Classics
    • List of Issues
  • Front Matter
  • News
    • For the Press
    • This Week In PNAS
    • PNAS in the News
  • Podcasts
  • Authors
    • Information for Authors
    • Editorial and Journal Policies
    • Submission Procedures
    • Fees and Licenses
  • Submit
  • About
    • Editorial Board
    • PNAS Staff
    • FAQ
    • Accessibility Statement
    • Rights and Permissions
    • Site Map
  • Contact
  • Journal Club
  • Subscribe
    • Subscription Rates
    • Subscriptions FAQ
    • Open Access
    • Recommend PNAS to Your Librarian

User menu

  • Log in
  • My Cart

Search

  • Advanced search
Home
Home

Advanced Search

  • Home
  • Articles
    • Current
    • Special Feature Articles - Most Recent
    • Special Features
    • Colloquia
    • Collected Articles
    • PNAS Classics
    • List of Issues
  • Front Matter
  • News
    • For the Press
    • This Week In PNAS
    • PNAS in the News
  • Podcasts
  • Authors
    • Information for Authors
    • Editorial and Journal Policies
    • Submission Procedures
    • Fees and Licenses

New Research In

Physical Sciences

Featured Portals

  • Physics
  • Chemistry
  • Sustainability Science

Articles by Topic

  • Applied Mathematics
  • Applied Physical Sciences
  • Astronomy
  • Computer Sciences
  • Earth, Atmospheric, and Planetary Sciences
  • Engineering
  • Environmental Sciences
  • Mathematics
  • Statistics

Social Sciences

Featured Portals

  • Anthropology
  • Sustainability Science

Articles by Topic

  • Economic Sciences
  • Environmental Sciences
  • Political Sciences
  • Psychological and Cognitive Sciences
  • Social Sciences

Biological Sciences

Featured Portals

  • Sustainability Science

Articles by Topic

  • Agricultural Sciences
  • Anthropology
  • Applied Biological Sciences
  • Biochemistry
  • Biophysics and Computational Biology
  • Cell Biology
  • Developmental Biology
  • Ecology
  • Environmental Sciences
  • Evolution
  • Genetics
  • Immunology and Inflammation
  • Medical Sciences
  • Microbiology
  • Neuroscience
  • Pharmacology
  • Physiology
  • Plant Biology
  • Population Biology
  • Psychological and Cognitive Sciences
  • Sustainability Science
  • Systems Biology
Letter

Reply to Davies: Hydraulic fracturing remains a possible mechanism for observed methane contamination of drinking water

Robert B. Jackson, Stephen G. Osborn, Avner Vengosh, and Nathaniel R. Warner
PNAS October 25, 2011 108 (43) E872; https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1113768108
Robert B. Jackson
  • Find this author on Google Scholar
  • Find this author on PubMed
  • Search for this author on this site
  • For correspondence: jackson@duke.edu
Stephen G. Osborn
  • Find this author on Google Scholar
  • Find this author on PubMed
  • Search for this author on this site
Avner Vengosh
  • Find this author on Google Scholar
  • Find this author on PubMed
  • Search for this author on this site
Nathaniel R. Warner
  • Find this author on Google Scholar
  • Find this author on PubMed
  • Search for this author on this site
  • Article
  • Info & Metrics
  • PDF
Loading

Davies (1) agrees that methane contamination of drinking water has occurred in aquifers overlying the Marcellus formation but asserts that we prematurely ascribed its cause to hydraulic fracturing (2). We respond briefly, noting that we carefully avoided ascribing any mechanism and suggested some additional research (2) for the important need that Davies (1) identifies—to understand the mechanism of contamination better. Comments about sampling procedures and methane seeps are in refs. 3 and 4.

Our paper discussed three mechanisms for stray gas migration (2). One was physical displacement of gas-rich water up from the shale formation, which we dismissed as “unlikely” (2). The other two mechanisms were leaky gas well casings and the possibility that hydraulic fracturing might generate new or enlarge existing fractures above the target formation, increasing connectivity. Of these two mechanisms, we wrote that “methane migration through the 1- to 2-km-thick geological formations that overlie the Marcellus and Utica shales is less likely as a mechanism for methane contamination than leaky well casings” (2).

The mechanism of leaky casings that Davies (1) also prefers does not rule out the possibility of fracture flow in a naturally fractured system. Reference 3 in the work by Davies (1) specifically acknowledges fracture flow for gas migration in Saskatchewan: “the coincidence of CH4 and He anomalies with known tectonic features also indicates fracture leakage from depth” (ref. 1 and reference 3 therein). Davies (1) also highlights the potential role of gas migration through orphaned wells, something unlikely to explain our results. The Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection's public database of gas well locations shows that only 3 of ∼8,000 orphaned wells are found in Susquehanna, Bradford, and Wayne counties (ref. 1 and references therein).

The problem with our paper (2) seems to be that we acknowledged the possibility of hydraulic fracturing playing a role. Is it possible that hydraulic fracturing increases system connectivity? It is. Is it also possible that the increasingly high pressures used in hydraulic fracturing, sometimes 1,000 atm, make leaks more likely? Perhaps. Neither is proven, and all possible explanations need more research.

Along with our previous research recommendations (1, 5) and Davies’ (1) call for microseismic and tiltmeter data, we offer two additional suggestions. One suggestion is the need for better geographic and stratigraphic data on the isotopic distributions of methane and ethane with depth, an area where industry disclosure could help. Distinguishing between methane in Marcellus shale (and other middle Devonian strata) from the methane found in shallower upper Devonian layers is currently difficult because of a lack of 13C and 2H data with depth.

The second need is for a public database of methane and ethane isotope values from each gas well. Requiring regular analyses of methane and ethane isotopes (13C and 2H), perhaps two times yearly, could also help researchers identify sources of stray gas.

In summary, we agree with Davies (1) that our “data showed that contamination had occurred, but the association with hydraulic fractures remains unproven” (1). Any assertion that hydraulic fracturing is unrelated to contamination remains equally unproven. We stand by what we wrote: “More research is needed across this and other regions to determine the mechanism(s) controlling the higher methane concentrations we observed” (2).

Footnotes

  • ↵1To whom correspondence should be addressed. E-mail: jackson{at}duke.edu.
  • Author contributions: R.B.J., S.G.O., A.V., and N.R.W. wrote the paper.

  • The authors declare no conflict of interest.

References

  1. ↵
    1. Davies RJ
    (2011) Methane contamination of drinking water caused by hydraulic fracturing remains unproven. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 108:E871.
    OpenUrlFREE Full Text
  2. ↵
    1. Osborn SG,
    2. Vengosh A,
    3. Warner NR,
    4. Jackson RB
    (2011) Methane contamination of drinking water accompanying gas-well drilling and hydraulic fracturing. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 108:8172–8176.
    OpenUrlAbstract/FREE Full Text
  3. ↵
    1. Osborn SG,
    2. Vengosh A,
    3. Warner NR,
    4. Jackson RB
    (2011) Reply to Saba and Orzechowski and Schon: Methane contamination of drinking water accompanying gas-well drilling and hydraulic fracturing. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 108:E665–E666.
    OpenUrlFREE Full Text
  4. ↵
    1. Jackson RB,
    2. Osborn SG,
    3. Warner NR,
    4. Vengosh A
    (2011) Responses to Frequently Asked Questions and Comments About the Shale-Gas Paper by Osborn et al, Available at http://www.nicholas.duke.edu/cgc/. Accessed June 15, 2011.
  5. ↵
    1. Jackson RB,
    2. Pearson BR,
    3. Osborn SG,
    4. Warner NR,
    5. Vengosh A
    (2011) Research and Policy Recommendations for Hydraulic Fracturing and Shale-Gas Extraction, Available at http://www.nicholas.duke.edu/cgc/. Accessed May 9, 2011.
PreviousNext
Back to top
Article Alerts
Email Article

Thank you for your interest in spreading the word on PNAS.

NOTE: We only request your email address so that the person you are recommending the page to knows that you wanted them to see it, and that it is not junk mail. We do not capture any email address.

Enter multiple addresses on separate lines or separate them with commas.
Reply to Davies: Hydraulic fracturing remains a possible mechanism for observed methane contamination of drinking water
(Your Name) has sent you a message from PNAS
(Your Name) thought you would like to see the PNAS web site.
CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
Citation Tools
Reply to Davies: Hydraulic fracturing remains a possible mechanism for observed methane contamination of drinking water
Robert B. Jackson, Stephen G. Osborn, Avner Vengosh, Nathaniel R. Warner
Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences Oct 2011, 108 (43) E872; DOI: 10.1073/pnas.1113768108

Citation Manager Formats

  • BibTeX
  • Bookends
  • EasyBib
  • EndNote (tagged)
  • EndNote 8 (xml)
  • Medlars
  • Mendeley
  • Papers
  • RefWorks Tagged
  • Ref Manager
  • RIS
  • Zotero
Request Permissions
Share
Reply to Davies: Hydraulic fracturing remains a possible mechanism for observed methane contamination of drinking water
Robert B. Jackson, Stephen G. Osborn, Avner Vengosh, Nathaniel R. Warner
Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences Oct 2011, 108 (43) E872; DOI: 10.1073/pnas.1113768108
Digg logo Reddit logo Twitter logo Facebook logo Google logo Mendeley logo
  • Tweet Widget
  • Facebook Like
  • Mendeley logo Mendeley
Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences: 108 (43)
Table of Contents

Submit

Sign up for Article Alerts

Jump to section

  • Article
    • Footnotes
    • References
  • Info & Metrics
  • PDF

You May Also be Interested in

Surgeons hands during surgery
Inner Workings: Advances in infectious disease treatment promise to expand the pool of donor organs
Despite myriad challenges, clinicians see room for progress.
Image credit: Shutterstock/David Tadevosian.
Setting sun over a sun-baked dirt landscape
Core Concept: Popular integrated assessment climate policy models have key caveats
Better explicating the strengths and shortcomings of these models will help refine projections and improve transparency in the years ahead.
Image credit: Witsawat.S.
Double helix
Journal Club: Noncoding DNA shown to underlie function, cause limb malformations
Using CRISPR, researchers showed that a region some used to label “junk DNA” has a major role in a rare genetic disorder.
Image credit: Nathan Devery.
Steamboat Geyser eruption.
Eruption of Steamboat Geyser
Mara Reed and Michael Manga explore why Yellowstone's Steamboat Geyser resumed erupting in 2018.
Listen
Past PodcastsSubscribe
Multi-color molecular model
Enzymatic breakdown of PET plastic
A study demonstrates how two enzymes—MHETase and PETase—work synergistically to depolymerize the plastic pollutant PET.
Image credit: Aaron McGeehan (artist).

Similar Articles

Site Logo
Powered by HighWire
  • Submit Manuscript
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • RSS Feeds
  • Email Alerts

Articles

  • Current Issue
  • Special Feature Articles – Most Recent
  • List of Issues

PNAS Portals

  • Anthropology
  • Chemistry
  • Classics
  • Front Matter
  • Physics
  • Sustainability Science
  • Teaching Resources

Information

  • Authors
  • Editorial Board
  • Reviewers
  • Librarians
  • Press
  • Site Map
  • PNAS Updates

Feedback    Privacy/Legal

Copyright © 2021 National Academy of Sciences. Online ISSN 1091-6490