Symbiotic bacteria appear to mediate hyena social odors
See allHide authors and affiliations
Edited by E. Peter Greenberg, University of Washington, Seattle, WA, and approved October 15, 2013 (received for review April 6, 2013)

Online Impact
Article Information
- Published in issue December 3, 2013.
- Published first November 11, 2013.
Author Information
- Kevin R. Theisa,b,1,
- Arvind Venkataramana,
- Jacquelyn A. Dycusa,
- Keith D. Koontera,
- Emily N. Schmitt-Matzena,
- Aaron P. Wagnerb,
- Kay E. Holekampb,c,2, and
- Thomas M. Schmidta,b,2
- Departments of aMicrobiology and Molecular Genetics and
- cZoology and
- bBEACON Center for the Study of Evolution in Action, Michigan State University, East Lansing, MI 48824
Edited by E. Peter Greenberg, University of Washington, Seattle, WA, and approved October 15, 2013 (received for review April 6, 2013)
Footnotes
- ↵1To whom correspondence should be addressed. E-mail: theiskev{at}msu.edu.
↵2K.E.H. and T.M.S. contributed equally to this work.
Author contributions: K.R.T., A.V., K.E.H., and T.M.S. designed research; K.R.T., A.V., J.A.D., K.D.K., E.N.S.-M., and A.P.W. performed research; K.R.T., A.V., and J.A.D. analyzed data; and K.R.T., A.V., J.A.D., A.P.W., K.E.H., and T.M.S. wrote the paper.
The authors declare no conflict of interest.
This article is a PNAS Direct Submission.
Data deposition: The sequences reported in this paper have been deposited in the GenBank database (accession nos. KC705471–KC706325).
This article contains supporting information online at www.pnas.org/lookup/suppl/doi:10.1073/pnas.1306477110/-/DCSupplemental.
Cited By...
This article has been cited by the following articles in journals that are participating in Crossref Cited-by Linking.
- Seth R. Bordenstein, Kevin R. Theis, Matthew K. WaldorPLOS Biology 2015 13 8
- Timothy R. Sampson, Sarkis K. MazmanianCell Host & Microbe 2015 17 5
- Roman M. Stilling, Marcel van de Wouw, Gerard Clarke, Catherine Stanton, Timothy G. Dinan, John F. CryanNeurochemistry International 2016 99
- Helen E. Vuong, Jessica M. Yano, Thomas C. Fung, Elaine Y. HsiaoAnnual Review of Neuroscience 2017 40 1
- Hadar Neuman, Justine W. Debelius, Rob Knight, Omry Koren, Ehud BaninFEMS Microbiology Reviews 2015 39 4
- Scott F. Gilbert, Thomas C. G. Bosch, Cristina Ledón-RettigNature Reviews Genetics 2015 16 10
- Andrea J. Jani, Cheryl J. BriggsProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 2014 111 47
- J. Dylan Shropshire, Seth R. BordensteinmBio 2016 7 2
- Sofia Cussotto, Kiran V. Sandhu, Timothy G. Dinan, John F. CryanFrontiers in Neuroendocrinology 2018 51
- Elizabeth A Archie, Jenny TungCurrent Opinion in Behavioral Sciences 2015 6
- Vanessa O. Ezenwa, Allison E. WilliamsBioEssays 2014 36 9
- Eoin Sherwin, Seth R. Bordenstein, John L. Quinn, Timothy G. Dinan, John F. CryanScience 2019 366 6465
- Bacterial communities in meerkat anal scent secretions vary with host sex, age, and group membershipS. Leclaire, J. F. Nielsen, C. M. DreaBehavioral Ecology 2014 25 4
- Robert A. Raguso, Anurag A. Agrawal, Angela E. Douglas, Georg Jander, André Kessler, Katja Poveda, Jennifer S. ThalerEcology 2015 96 3
- Kevin D. Kohl, Hannah V. CareyThe Journal of Experimental Biology 2016 219 22
- J. J. Knack, L. W. Wilcox, P.-M. Delaux, J.-M. Ané, M. J. Piotrowski, M. E. Cook, J. M. Graham, L. E. GrahamInternational Journal of Plant Sciences 2015 176 5
- Martin A. Stoffel, Barbara A. Caspers, Jaume Forcada, Athina Giannakara, Markus Baier, Luke Eberhart-Phillips, Caroline Müller, Joseph I. HoffmanProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 2015 112 36
- Roman M Stilling, Gerard M Moloney, Feargal J Ryan, Alan E Hoban, Thomaz FS Bastiaanssen, Fergus Shanahan, Gerard Clarke, Marcus J Claesson, Timothy G Dinan, John F CryaneLife 2018 7
- Alexandra A. Mushegian, Dieter EbertBioEssays 2016 38 1
- Joseph E. Spraker, Kelsea Jewell, Ludmila V. Roze, Jacob Scherf, Dora Ndagano, Randolph Beaudry, John E. Linz, Caitilyn Allen, Nancy P. KellerJournal of Chemical Ecology 2014 40 5
- Douglas S. Pearce, Brian A. Hoover, Sarah Jennings, Gabrielle A. Nevitt, Kathryn M. DochertyMicrobiome 2017 5 1
- Sarah Leclaire, Staffan Jacob, Lydia K. Greene, George R. Dubay, Christine M. DreaScientific Reports 2017 7 1
- Kay E. Holekamp, Ben Dantzer, Gregory Stricker, Kathryn C. Shaw Yoshida, Sarah Benson-AmramAnimal Behaviour 2015 103
- A. E. Brunetti, F. Carnevale Neto, M. C. Vera, C. Taboada, D. P. Pavarini, A. Bauermeister, N. P. LopesChemical Society Reviews 2018 47 5
- E. A. McKenney, K. Koelle, R. R. Dunn, A. D. YoderMolecular Ecology 2018 27 8
- Taichi A. SuzukiIntegrative and Comparative Biology 2017 57 4
- Alexandra J.R. Carthey, Michael R. Gillings, Daniel T. BlumsteinTrends in Ecology & Evolution 2018 33 11
- Darren J. Parris, Rohan M. Brooker, Michael A. Morgan, Danielle L. Dixson, Frank J. StewartPeerJ 2016 4
- Aura Raulo, Lasse Ruokolainen, Avery Lane, Katherine Amato, Rob Knight, Steven Leigh, Rebecca Stumpf, Bryan White, Karen E. Nelson, Andrea L. Baden, Stacey R. Tecot, Audrey DussutourJournal of Animal Ecology 2018 87 2
- Jeremy Chase Crawford, Christine M. DreaBiology Letters 2015 11 2
- Emmanuelle Münger, Augusto J. Montiel-Castro, Wolfgang Langhans, Gustavo Pacheco-LópezFrontiers in Integrative Neuroscience 2018 12
- Brittany D. Needham, Weiyi Tang, Wei-Li WuDevelopmental Neurobiology 2018 78 5
- Cuong Quoc Nguyen, William John Thrift, Arunima Bhattacharjee, Saba Ranjbar, Tara Gallagher, Mahsa Darvishzadeh-Varcheie, Robert Noboru Sanderson, Filippo Capolino, Katrine Whiteson, Pierre Baldi, Allon I. Hochbaum, Regina RaganACS Applied Materials & Interfaces 2018 10 15
- Kamala Jayanthi Pagadala Damodaram, Arthikirubha Ayyasamy, Vivek KemprajMicrobial Ecology 2016 72 3
- Diyan Li, Binlong Chen, Long Zhang, Uma Gaur, Tianyuan Ma, Hang Jie, Guijun Zhao, Nan Wu, Zhongxian Xu, Huailiang Xu, Yongfang Yao, Ting Lian, Xiaolan Fan, Deying Yang, Mingyao Yang, Qing Zhu, Jessica Satkoski TraskScientific Reports 2016 6 1
- Oren Kolodny, Maya Weinberg, Leah Reshef, Lee Harten, Abraham Hefetz, Uri Gophna, Marcus W. Feldman, Yossi YovelNature Ecology & Evolution 2019 3 1
- Andy Dosmann, Nassim Bahet, Deborah M. GordonPeerJ 2016 4
- Melissah Rowe, Liisa Veerus, Pål Trosvik, Angus Buckling, Tommaso PizzariTrends in Ecology & Evolution 2020 35 3
- Agnieszka Sergiel, Javier Naves, Piotr Kujawski, Robert Maślak, Ewa Serwa, Damián Ramos, Alberto Fernández-Gil, Eloy Revilla, Tomasz Zwijacz-Kozica, Filip Zięba, Johanna Painer, Nuria SelvaScientific Reports 2017 7 1
- Lydia K. Greene, Kathleen E. Grogan, Kendra N. Smyth, Christine A. Adams, Skylar A. Klager, Christine M. DreaRoyal Society Open Science 2016 3 4
- Danielle J. Whittaker, Nicole M. Gerlach, Samuel P. Slowinski, Kyle P. Corcoran, Andrew D. Winters, Helena A. Soini, Milos V. Novotny, Ellen D. Ketterson, Kevin R. TheisFrontiers in Ecology and Evolution 2016 4
- Andrés E. Brunetti, Mariana L. Lyra, Weilan G. P. Melo, Laura E. Andrade, Pablo Palacios-Rodríguez, Bárbara M. Prado, Célio F. B. Haddad, Mônica T. Pupo, Norberto P. LopesProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 2019 116 6
- Heather L. Eisthen, Kevin R. TheisPhilosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 2016 371 1685
- Eric Bapteste, Philippe HunemanBMC Biology 2018 16 1
- Marlen Kücklich, Manfred Möller, Andrea Marcillo, Almuth Einspanier, Brigitte M. Weiß, Claudia Birkemeyer, Anja Widdig, Walter LealPLOS ONE 2017 12 8
- John Bienenstock, Wolfgang A. Kunze, Paul ForsytheBiological Reviews 2018 93 1
- Holly A. Coombes, Paula Stockley, Jane L. HurstJournal of Chemical Ecology 2018 44 9
- Kay E. Holekamp, Sarah Benson-AmramInterface Focus 2017 7 3
- Kevin D. KohlIntegrative and Comparative Biology 2017 57 4
- Öncü Maraci, Kathrin Engel, Barbara A. CaspersGenes 2018 9 8
- Kathrin Engel, Jan Sauer, Sebastian Jünemann, Anika Winkler, Daniel Wibberg, Jörn Kalinowski, Andreas Tauch, Barbara A. CaspersMicrobial Ecology 2018 76 2
- Jane Lucas, Brian Bill, Bradley Stevenson, Michael KaspariEcosphere 2017 8 2
- Kristina Linnea HilleslandAnnals of the New York Academy of Sciences 2018 1422 1
- Stefanie Grosser, Jan Sauer, Anneke J. Paijmans, Barbara A. Caspers, Jaume Forcada, Jochen B. W. Wolf, Joseph I. HoffmanMolecular Ecology 2019 28 9
- Lydia K. Greene, Sally L. Bornbusch, Erin A. McKenney, Rachel L. Harris, Sarah R. Gorvetzian, Anne D. Yoder, Christine M. DreaAmerican Journal of Primatology 2019 81 10-11
- Cristian Pasquaretta, Tamara Gómez-Moracho, Philipp Heeb, Mathieu LihoreauGenes 2018 9 11
- Joanne Shu Ming Chia, Elena S. Wall, Caroline Lei Wee, Thomas A. J. Rowland, Ruey-Kuang Cheng, Kathleen Cheow, Karen Guillemin, Suresh JesuthasanNature Communications 2019 10 1
- Christine M. DreaPhilosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 2020 375 1800
- Santiago Sandoval-Motta, Maximino Aldana, Alejandro FrankArchives of Medical Research 2017 48 8
- Danielle J. Whittaker, Samuel P. Slowinski, Jonathan M. Greenberg, Osama Alian, Andrew D. Winters, Madison M. Ahmad, Mikayla J. E. Burrell, Helena A. Soini, Milos V. Novotny, Ellen D. Ketterson, Kevin R. TheisThe Journal of Experimental Biology 2019 222 20
- Manuel Azcárate‐García, Magdalena Ruiz‐Rodríguez, Silvia Díaz‐Lora, Cristina Ruiz‐Castellano, Juan José SolerJournal of Avian Biology 2019 50 3
- Zoe A. Pratte, Nastassia V. Patin, Mary E. McWhirt, Alicia M. Caughman, Darren J. Parris, Frank J. StewartCoral Reefs 2018 37 4
- Raquel Xavier, Renata Mazzei, Marcos Pérez-Losada, Daniela Rosado, Joana L. Santos, Ana Veríssimo, Marta C. SoaresFrontiers in Microbiology 2019 10
- Connie A Rojas, Kay E Holekamp, Andrew D Winters, Kevin R TheisFEMS Microbiology Ecology 2020 96 2
- Brigitte M. Weiß, Marlen Kücklich, Ruth Thomsen, Stefanie Henkel, Susann Jänig, Lars Kulik, Claudia Birkemeyer, Anja WiddigBehavioral Ecology and Sociobiology 2018 72 4
- Alexandra J. R. Carthey, Daniel T. Blumstein, Rachael V. Gallagher, Sasha G. Tetu, Michael R. Gillings, Alison BennettFunctional Ecology 2020 34 4
- Michael J. Noonan, Helga V. Tinnesand, Christina D. BueschingBioEssays 2018 40 6
- Amar Sarkar, Siobhán Harty, Katerina V.‐A. Johnson, Andrew H. Moeller, Rachel N. Carmody, Soili M. Lehto, Susan E. Erdman, Robin I. M. Dunbar, Philip W. J. BurnetBiological Reviews 2020 95 5
- Christina D. Buesching, H. Veronica Tinnesand, YungWa Sin, Frank Rosell, Terry Burke, David W. Macdonald2016
- Birte L. Nielsen, Nathalie Jérôme, Audrey Saint-Albin, Fatima Joly, Sylvie Rabot, Nicolas MeunierBehavioural Brain Research 2019 359
- Kevin R. Theis, Arvind Venkataraman, Aaron P. Wagner, Kay E. Holekamp, Thomas M. Schmidt2016
- Alexandre R. T. Figueiredo, Jos KramerFrontiers in Ecology and Evolution 2020 8
- Kathleen E. Grogan, Rachel L. Harris, Marylène Boulet, Christine M. DreaBMC Evolutionary Biology 2019 19 1
- Yimeng Li, Tianxiang Zhang, Lei Qi, Shuang Yang, Shanghua Xu, Muha Cha, Meishan Zhang, Zhixin Huang, Juan Yu, Defu Hu, Shuqiang LiuFrontiers in Microbiology 2018 9
- Osiris Gaona, Daniel Cerqueda-García, Luisa I. Falcón, Guillermo Vázquez-Domínguez, Patricia M. Valdespino-Castillo, Carla-Ximena Neri-Barrios, Brenda A WilsonPLOS ONE 2019 14 12
- Andrew S. Flies, Matthew T. Maksimoski, Linda S. Mansfield, Mary L. Weldele, Kay E. HolekampVeterinary Research Communications 2014 38 2
- Thomas E. Goodwin, Innocent H. Harelimana, Laura J. MacDonald, Daniel B. Mark, Aline Umuhire Juru, Qin Yin, James A. Engman, Randall A. Kopper, Cheryl F. Lichti, Samuel G. Mackintosh, James D. Shoemaker, Mark V. Sutherland, Alan J. Tackett, Bruce A. Schulte2016
- Chris G. Faulkes, J. Stephen Elmore, David A. Baines, Brock Fenton, Nancy B. Simmons, Elizabeth L. ClarePeerJ 2019 7
- Danielle J. Whittaker, Meredith Kuzel, Mikayla J.E. Burrell, Helena A. Soini, Milos V. Novotny, Emily H. DuValAnimal Behaviour 2019 151
- Sahana Kuthyar, Melissa B Manus, Katherine R AmatoCurrent Opinion in Microbiology 2019 50
- J. Mitchell, M. A. Cant, H. J. NicholsBiology Letters 2017 13 11
- Marta C. Soares, Jo Cable, Monica G. Lima‐Maximino, Caio Maximino, Raquel XavierFish and Fisheries 2019
- C. Jessica E. Metcalf, Lucas P. Henry, María Rebolleda-Gómez, Britt Koskella, Stephen Stearns, David S. GuttmanmBio 2019 10 5
- Mei S. Yamaguchi, Holly H. Ganz, Adrienne W. Cho, Thant H. Zaw, Guillaume Jospin, Mitchell M. McCartney, Cristina E. Davis, Jonathan A. Eisen, David A. Coil, Marcos Egea-CortinesPLOS ONE 2019 14 9
- Susann Jänig, Brigitte M. Weiß, Claudia Birkemeyer, Anja WiddigAmerican Journal of Primatology 2019
- Eva C. Wikberg, Diana Christie, Pascale Sicotte, Nelson TingAnimal Behaviour 2020 163
- Srinivasan Mahalingam, Dhanasekaran Dharumadurai, Govindaraju ArchunanSymbiosis 2019 78 1
- Tina Netzker, Evan M.F. Shepherdson, Matthew P. Zambri, Marie A. ElliotAnnual Review of Microbiology 2020 74 1
- Marlen Kücklich, Brigitte M. Weiß, Claudia Birkemeyer, Almuth Einspanier, Anja WiddigScientific Reports 2019 9 1
- Wei Guo, Ke Ren, Ruihong Ning, Caiwu Li, Hemin Zhang, Desheng Li, Lin Xu, Fenghui Sun, Min DaiGlobal Ecology and Conservation 2020 24
- Lucie Schmiedová, Jakub Kreisinger, Milica Požgayová, Marcel Honza, Jean-François Martin, Petr ProcházkaFEMS Microbiology Ecology 2020 96 9
- M. Eric Benbow, Jennifer L. Pechal, Jeffery K. Tomberlin, Heather R. Jordan2018 5
- María Rebolleda-Gómez, Corlett Wolfe WoodFrontiers in Ecology and Evolution 2019 7
- S. Vaissi, M. Sharifi, A. Hernandez, S. Nikpey, M. TaranInternational Zoo Yearbook 2019 53 1
- Mónica Mazorra-Alonso, Manuel Martín-Vivaldi, Juan Manuel Peralta-Sánchez, Juan José SolerBiology 2020 9 10
- Stephen T. Trumbo, Paula K. B. Philbrick, Johannes Stökl, Sandra SteigerThe American Naturalist 2021 197 3
- Chloé Vigliotti, Cédric Bicep, Eric Bapteste, Philippe Lopez, Eduardo Corel2019
- Muhammad Afzal, Sayyeda Farwa Mazhar, Sadia Sana, Muhammad Naeem, Muhammad Hidayat Rasool, Muhammad Saqalein, Muhammad Atif Nisar, Maria Rasool, Muhammad Bilal, Abdul Arif Khan, Mohsin KhurshidFuture Microbiology 2020 15 11
- M. Srinivasan, M. Adnane, G. ArchunanResearch in Veterinary Science 2021 135
- Wenliang Zhou, Dunwu Qi, Ronald R. Swaisgood, Le Wang, Yipeng Jin, Qi Wu, Fuwen Wei, Yonggang NieThe ISME Journal 2021
- Anna M. O’Brien, Chandra N. Jack, Maren L. Friesen, Megan E. FredericksonProceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 2021 288 1942
- Kevin D. Kohl, M. Denise DearingIntegrative and Comparative Biology 2017 57 4
- Mauro Giuffrè, Rita Moretti, Giuseppina Campisciano, Alexandre Barcelos Morais da Silveira, Vincenzo Maria Monda, Manola Comar, Stefano Di Bella, Roberta Maria Antonello, Roberto Luzzati, Lory Saveria CrocèJournal of Clinical Medicine 2020 9 11
Article usage
Citation Manager Formats
Article Classifications
- Biological Sciences
- Ecology