Skip to main content
  • Submit
  • About
    • Editorial Board
    • PNAS Staff
    • FAQ
    • Rights and Permissions
    • Site Map
  • Contact
  • Journal Club
  • Subscribe
    • Subscription Rates
    • Subscriptions FAQ
    • Open Access
    • Recommend PNAS to Your Librarian
  • Log in
  • My Cart

Main menu

  • Home
  • Articles
    • Current
    • Latest Articles
    • Special Features
    • Colloquia
    • Collected Articles
    • PNAS Classics
    • Archive
  • Front Matter
  • News
    • For the Press
    • Highlights from Latest Articles
    • PNAS in the News
  • Podcasts
  • Authors
    • Information for Authors
    • Purpose and Scope
    • Editorial and Journal Policies
    • Submission Procedures
    • For Reviewers
    • Author FAQ
  • Submit
  • About
    • Editorial Board
    • PNAS Staff
    • FAQ
    • Rights and Permissions
    • Site Map
  • Contact
  • Journal Club
  • Subscribe
    • Subscription Rates
    • Subscriptions FAQ
    • Open Access
    • Recommend PNAS to Your Librarian

User menu

  • Log in
  • My Cart

Search

  • Advanced search
Home
Home

Advanced Search

  • Home
  • Articles
    • Current
    • Latest Articles
    • Special Features
    • Colloquia
    • Collected Articles
    • PNAS Classics
    • Archive
  • Front Matter
  • News
    • For the Press
    • Highlights from Latest Articles
    • PNAS in the News
  • Podcasts
  • Authors
    • Information for Authors
    • Purpose and Scope
    • Editorial and Journal Policies
    • Submission Procedures
    • For Reviewers
    • Author FAQ

New Research In

Physical Sciences

Featured Portals

  • Physics
  • Chemistry
  • Sustainability Science

Articles by Topic

  • Applied Mathematics
  • Applied Physical Sciences
  • Astronomy
  • Computer Sciences
  • Earth, Atmospheric, and Planetary Sciences
  • Engineering
  • Environmental Sciences
  • Mathematics
  • Statistics

Social Sciences

Featured Portals

  • Anthropology
  • Sustainability Science

Articles by Topic

  • Economic Sciences
  • Environmental Sciences
  • Political Sciences
  • Psychological and Cognitive Sciences
  • Social Sciences

Biological Sciences

Featured Portals

  • Sustainability Science

Articles by Topic

  • Agricultural Sciences
  • Anthropology
  • Applied Biological Sciences
  • Biochemistry
  • Biophysics and Computational Biology
  • Cell Biology
  • Developmental Biology
  • Ecology
  • Environmental Sciences
  • Evolution
  • Genetics
  • Immunology and Inflammation
  • Medical Sciences
  • Microbiology
  • Neuroscience
  • Pharmacology
  • Physiology
  • Plant Biology
  • Population Biology
  • Psychological and Cognitive Sciences
  • Sustainability Science
  • Systems Biology

Inconclusive evidence of Juniperus virginiana recovery following sulfur pollution reductions

Paul G. Schaberg, Gary J. Hawley, Shelly A. Rayback, Joshua M. Halman, and Alexandra M. Kosiba
PNAS January 7, 2014 111 (1) E1; published ahead of print December 27, 2013 https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1320526111
Paul G. Schaberg
aNorthern Research Station, US Forest Service, Burlington, VT 05405; and
  • Find this author on Google Scholar
  • Find this author on PubMed
  • Search for this author on this site
  • For correspondence: pschaberg@fs.fed.us
Gary J. Hawley
bRubenstein School of Environment and Natural Resources and
  • Find this author on Google Scholar
  • Find this author on PubMed
  • Search for this author on this site
Shelly A. Rayback
cDepartment of Geography, University of Vermont, Burlington, VT 05405
  • Find this author on Google Scholar
  • Find this author on PubMed
  • Search for this author on this site
Joshua M. Halman
bRubenstein School of Environment and Natural Resources and
  • Find this author on Google Scholar
  • Find this author on PubMed
  • Search for this author on this site
Alexandra M. Kosiba
bRubenstein School of Environment and Natural Resources and
  • Find this author on Google Scholar
  • Find this author on PubMed
  • Search for this author on this site

This article has letters. Please see:

  • Evidence of recovery of Juniperus virginiana trees from sulfur pollution after the Clean Air Act
  • Reply to Schaberg et al.: Applying stable isotope analyses to examine the influence of acid deposition on Juniperus virginiana
  • Article
  • Info & Metrics
  • PDF
Loading

Thomas et al. (1) address a question of great scientific interest: have pollution reductions mandated by the Clean Air Act improved forest health and productivity? Although answers to this question are of great importance, various aspects of this work limit its ability to address this question.

First is the surprising choice of a test species. The bulk of the literature that addresses acid deposition impacts on US trees focuses on two sensitive species: Picea rubens and Acer saccharum. A plethora of laboratory- and field-based studies using these species have provided a remarkably detailed mechanistic understanding of how pollutant additions of hydrogen ions (H+) disrupt base cation relations (reducing Ca and increasing Al availability), which then alter tree stress response and carbon relations (e.g., ref. 2). In contrast, we are not aware of any decline in Juniperus virginiana associated with acid deposition, and found only one study that assessed its sensitivity to precipitation acidity, which reported no impacts on aboveground or belowground growth (3).

Building on this finding, the mechanisms discussed in Thomas et al. (1) show little connection to accepted understandings of how acid deposition impacts trees. For example, although much incoming acidity historically originated with S pollution, it has been shown that H+ inputs are the disrupting agent, not S itself (2, 4). Thus, analyses of S in wood rather than the more accepted analyses of Ca and Al seem misplaced. Even the alleged connection between S addition and stomatal function is actually an H+ and Ca influence (S concentration was equalized between the treatments in ref. 4 cited by ref. 1). The mechanism whereby gaseous sulfur dioxide induces stomatal closure is separate from the influence of acid deposition.

The test location and low sample size used in Thomas et al. (1) are also problematic. The single site evaluated was on a limestone outcrop, a location well buffered against acid deposition-induced soil Ca depletion and Al mobilization. Furthermore, only five trees of greatly varying age were sampled to provide evidence of species recovery, likely contributing to a low expressed population signal for basal area increment: below the 0.85 standard (5).

Finally, there are some inconsistencies in the timeline discussed in Thomas et al. (1). First, it seems odd that the net positive changes in estimated C assimilation and stomatal conductance in the 1930s were attributed to acid deposition when this phenomenon was not reported for the United States until 1972 following long-term monitoring at the Hubbard Brook Experimental Forest in New Hampshire. Second, it is questionable whether the change in δ13C in 1982 would have occurred when S deposition remained at near record levels (figure 1 in ref. 1). Furthermore, it appears that growth increases began around 1970, before the proposed 1982 turning point in δ13C.

Overall, the timing and context of the Thomas et al. (1) study are important, and some of the methods used are potentially powerful tools for answering questions about the influence of pollution reductions on tree health and productivity. However, various limitations of the current study of Juniperus virginiana’s possible recovery from S pollution after the Clean Air Act render it inconclusive.

Footnotes

  • ↵1To whom correspondence may be addressed. E-mail: pschaberg{at}fs.fed.us.
  • Author contributions: P.G.S., G.J.H., S.A.R., J.M.H., and A.M.K. wrote the paper.

  • The authors declare no conflict of interest.

References

  1. ↵
    1. Thomas RB,
    2. Spal SE,
    3. Smith KR,
    4. Nippert JB
    (2013) Evidence of recovery of Juniperus virginiana trees from sulfur pollution after the Clean Air Act. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 110(38):15319–15324.
    OpenUrlAbstract/FREE Full Text
  2. ↵
    1. DeHayes DH,
    2. Schaberg PG,
    3. Hawley GJ,
    4. Strimbeck GR
    (1999) Acid rain impacts on calcium nutrition and forest health. Bioscience 49(10):789–800.
    OpenUrlFREE Full Text
  3. ↵
    1. Lee JJ,
    2. Weber DE
    (1979) The effect of simulated acid rain on seedling emergence and growth of eleven woody species. Forest Sci 25(3):393–398.
    OpenUrl
  4. ↵
    1. Borer CH,
    2. Schaberg PG,
    3. DeHayes DH
    (2005) Acidic mist reduces foliar membrane-associated calcium and impairs stomatal responsiveness in red spruce. Tree Physiol 25(6):673–680.
    OpenUrlAbstract/FREE Full Text
  5. ↵
    1. Wigley TML,
    2. Briffa KR,
    3. Jones PD
    (1984) On the average value of correlated timeseries, with applications in dendroclimatology and hydrometerology. J Clim Appl Meteorol 23(2):201–213.
    OpenUrlCrossRef
View Abstract
PreviousNext
Back to top
Article Alerts
Email Article

Thank you for your interest in spreading the word on PNAS.

NOTE: We only request your email address so that the person you are recommending the page to knows that you wanted them to see it, and that it is not junk mail. We do not capture any email address.

Enter multiple addresses on separate lines or separate them with commas.
Inconclusive evidence of Juniperus virginiana recovery following sulfur pollution reductions
(Your Name) has sent you a message from PNAS
(Your Name) thought you would like to see the PNAS web site.
Citation Tools
Recovery of Juniperus virginiana is inconclusive
Paul G. Schaberg, Gary J. Hawley, Shelly A. Rayback, Joshua M. Halman, Alexandra M. Kosiba
Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences Jan 2014, 111 (1) E1; DOI: 10.1073/pnas.1320526111

Citation Manager Formats

  • BibTeX
  • Bookends
  • EasyBib
  • EndNote (tagged)
  • EndNote 8 (xml)
  • Medlars
  • Mendeley
  • Papers
  • RefWorks Tagged
  • Ref Manager
  • RIS
  • Zotero
Request Permissions
Share
Recovery of Juniperus virginiana is inconclusive
Paul G. Schaberg, Gary J. Hawley, Shelly A. Rayback, Joshua M. Halman, Alexandra M. Kosiba
Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences Jan 2014, 111 (1) E1; DOI: 10.1073/pnas.1320526111
del.icio.us logo Digg logo Reddit logo Twitter logo CiteULike logo Facebook logo Google logo Mendeley logo
  • Tweet Widget
  • Facebook Like
  • Mendeley logo Mendeley
Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences: 116 (8)
Current Issue

Submit

Sign up for Article Alerts

Jump to section

  • Article
    • Footnotes
    • References
  • Info & Metrics
  • PDF

You May Also be Interested in

News Feature: Cities serve as testbeds for evolutionary change
Urban living can pressure flora and fauna to adapt in intriguing ways. Biologists are starting to take advantage of this convenient laboratory of evolution.
Image credit: Kristin Winchell (Washington University in St. Louis, St. Louis).
Several aspects of the proposal, which aims to expand open access, require serious discussion and, in some cases, a rethink.
Opinion: “Plan S” falls short for society publishers—and for the researchers they serve
Several aspects of the proposal, which aims to expand open access, require serious discussion and, in some cases, a rethink.
Image credit: Dave Cutler (artist).
Featured Profile
PNAS Profile of NAS member and biochemist Hao Wu
 Nonmonogamous strawberry poison frog (Oophaga pumilio).  Image courtesy of Yusan Yang (University of Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh).
Putative signature of monogamy
A study suggests a putative gene-expression hallmark common to monogamous male vertebrates of some species, namely cichlid fishes, dendrobatid frogs, passeroid songbirds, common voles, and deer mice, and identifies 24 candidate genes potentially associated with monogamy.
Image courtesy of Yusan Yang (University of Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh).
Active lifestyles. Image courtesy of Pixabay/MabelAmber.
Meaningful life tied to healthy aging
Physical and social well-being in old age are linked to self-assessments of life worth, and a spectrum of behavioral, economic, health, and social variables may influence whether aging individuals believe they are leading meaningful lives.
Image courtesy of Pixabay/MabelAmber.

More Articles of This Classification

  • Improving integration in societal consequences to climate change
  • Reply to Jaffe et al.: Paleoscience precision in an archeological or historical context
  • Need for early, minimally invasive cancer diagnosis
Show more

Related Content

  • Recovery of trees after the Clean Air Act
  • Stable isotopes and effects of acid deposition
  • Scopus
  • PubMed
  • Google Scholar

Cited by...

  • Reply to Schaberg et al.: Applying stable isotope analyses to examine the influence of acid deposition on Juniperus virginiana
  • Scopus (2)
  • Google Scholar

Similar Articles

Site Logo
Powered by HighWire
  • Submit Manuscript
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • RSS Feeds
  • Email Alerts

Articles

  • Current Issue
  • Latest Articles
  • Archive

PNAS Portals

  • Classics
  • Front Matter
  • Teaching Resources
  • Anthropology
  • Chemistry
  • Physics
  • Sustainability Science

Information

  • Authors
  • Editorial Board
  • Reviewers
  • Press
  • Site Map

Feedback    Privacy/Legal

Copyright © 2019 National Academy of Sciences. Online ISSN 1091-6490