Ethics in field experimentation: A call to establish new standards to protect the public from unwanted manipulation and real harms
See allHide authors and affiliations
Edited by Margaret Levi, Stanford University, Stanford, CA, and approved October 1, 2020 (received for review June 10, 2020)

Abstract
In 1966, Henry Beecher published his foundational paper “Ethics and Clinical Research,” bringing to light unethical experiments that were routinely being conducted by leading universities and government agencies. A common theme was the lack of voluntary consent. Research regulations surrounding laboratory experiments flourished after his work. More than half a century later, we seek to follow in his footsteps and identify a new domain of risk to the public: certain types of field experiments. The nature of experimental research has changed greatly since the Belmont Report. Due in part to technological advances including social media, experimenters now target and affect whole societies, releasing interventions into a living public, often without sufficient review or controls. A large number of social science field experiments do not reflect compliance with current ethical and legal requirements that govern research with human participants. Real-world interventions are being conducted without consent or notice to the public they affect. Follow-ups and debriefing are routinely not being undertaken with the populations that experimenters injure. Importantly, even when ethical research guidelines are followed, researchers are following principles developed for experiments in controlled settings, with little assessment or protection for the wider societies within which individuals are embedded. We strive to improve the ethics of future work by advocating the creation of new norms, illustrating classes of field experiments where scholars do not appear to have recognized the ways such research circumvents ethical standards by putting people, including those outside the manipulated group, into harm’s way.
Footnotes
- ↵1To whom correspondence may be addressed. Email: Phatemi{at}gmail.com.
Author contributions: R.M. and P.K.H. designed research, performed research, and wrote the paper.
The authors declare no competing interest.
This article is a PNAS Direct Submission.
Data Availability.
There are no data underlying this work.
Published under the PNAS license.
References
- ↵
- D. L. Teele
- ↵
- D. Baldassarri,
- M. Abascal
- ↵
- R. Meyer
- ↵
- B. Lerner
- ↵
- M. Wood
- ↵
- J. Jouhki,
- E. Lauk,
- M. Penttinen,
- N. Sormanen,
- T. Uskali
- ↵
- G. H. McClendon
- ↵
- K. Peyton
- ↵
- Nuremberg Military Tribunals
- ↵
- World Medical Association
- ↵
- National Commission for the Protection of Human Subjects of Biomedical and Behavioral Research
- ↵
- C. A. Bail et al
- ↵
- D. Broockman,
- J. Kalla
- ↵
- J. Barceló
- ↵
- D. W. Nickerson,
- I. K. White
- ↵
- G. Nair,
- N. Sambanis
- ↵
- L. Bursztyn,
- D. Cantoni,
- D. Y. Yang,
- N. Yuchtman,
- Y. J. Zhang
- ↵
- D. Willis
- ↵
- J. Kleinsman,
- S. Buckley
- ↵
- M. R. Michelson
- ↵
- A. Chong,
- O. A. L. De La,
- D. Karlan,
- L. Wantchekon
- ↵
- ↵
- ↵
- ↵
- C. Panagopoulos
- ↵
- R. D. Enos,
- A. Fowler,
- L. Vavreck
- ↵
- L. D. Walker
- ↵
- K. Dams-O’Connor,
- J. M. Ketchum,
- J. P. Cuthbert
- S. Holm,
- S. Madsen
- ↵
- American Psychological Association
- ↵
- S. Desposato
- ↵
- ↵
- A. S. Gerber,
- G. A. Huber,
- A. H. Fang,
- A. Gooch
- ↵
- A. S. Gerber,
- D. P. Green,
- C. W. Larimer
- ↵
- NIMH
- ↵
- R. W. Booth,
- B. Mackintosh,
- D. Sharma
- ↵
- ↵
- ↵
- ↵
- A. D. Kramer,
- J. E. Guillory,
- J. T. Hancock
- ↵
- D. Broockman
- ↵
- R. B. Morton,
- K. C. Williams
- ↵
- National Research Council, Population Co
- ↵
- C. Buckley
- ↵
- ↵
- N. S. Murshid,
- F. M. Critelli
- ↵
- J. D. Foltz,
- K. A. Opoku-Agyemang
- ↵
- G. D. Ruxton,
- T. Mulder
- ↵
- H. Algahtani,
- M. Bajunaid,
- B. Shirah
- ↵
- D. P. Green
Log in using your username and password
Log in through your institution
Purchase access
Subscribers, for more details, please visit our Subscriptions FAQ.
Please click here to log into the PNAS submission website.
Citation Manager Formats
Article Classifications
- Social Sciences
- Political Sciences