Early atmospheric contamination on the top of the Himalayas since the onset of the European Industrial Revolution

Results and Discussion

We present records for the concentrations of 23 trace metals (Al, As, Ba, Bi, Cd, Co, Cr, Cs, Fe, Ga, Mg, Mn, Mo, Nb, Ni, Pb, Rb, Sb, Ti, Tl, U, V, and Zn) determined in the C3 Dasuopu ice core (see Methods) over the time interval 1499 to 1992 AD. Trace metal concentrations (Fig. 2 and SI Appendix, Figs. S1 and S2 and Table S1) are extremely variable in the Dasuopu core, with values ranging from 100 ng⋅g⁻¹ for typical crustal elements, such as Al and Fe, to picogram⋅gram⁻¹ and subpicogram⋅gram⁻¹ levels for ultratrace metals such as, Cr, Sb, Tl, Pb, and Bi, which are comparable to concentrations found in the Arctic snow and ice (33, 36, 37).

The annual/seasonal variability of trace metal concentrations is well recorded and very high, typically two orders of magnitude, with peak crustal elements concentrations occurring during the winter to spring months (SI Appendix, Figs. S3–S5). Concentration variability is much lower from 1499 to ∼1700 AD, because of diffusion due to the thinning of ice layers at greater englacial depths. Notably, as illustrated by the decadal median trends, most of the trace metal concentrations show a significant wide minimum during the 19th century (Fig. 2 and SI Appendix, Figs. S1 and S2). Importantly, a corresponding wide minimum can also be observed in the Dasuopu core in the decadal median of different proxies other than trace metals, such as for instance dust particles (35) and sulfate (38) (Fig. 2).

In this context, an increase in snow accumulation rate (from ∼100 to ∼150 cm w.e. per y) and a concomitant minimum in deuterium excess are observed between 1810 and 1880 AD (Fig. 2). It is important to note that the synchronous variation in snow accumulation and deuterium excess rules out glacial dynamic postdepositional effects (e.g., significant horizontal flow altering the snow layers). We note that the observed decreases in trace metal concentrations (e.g., Al and As) are compensated for by the increase in snow accumulation such that the calculated fluxes (e.g., Al concentration × snow accumulation; Fig. 2) show limited variability over the entire 500-y ice core record (SI Appendix, Table S2), with the exception of the 1970 to 1980 decade, when high crustal species are recorded. We conclude that the broad 19th-century minimum for most trace metal concentrations was mainly caused by the 50% increase in snow accumulation that diluted the dominant dry fallout of the chemical species.

Arsenic (As) is a trace element that is well known to be widely enriched in Tibetan Plateau soil dust (39) and occasionally also in central India rocks (40). We use the elemental composition of soil dust collected from Tibet as a crustal standard and Fe as crustal elemental reference to calculate EF (29). In this case, EFs of As and Al are rather constant and close to 1 through the entire 500-y record (Fig. 2), suggesting a constant origin of aeolian dust from the Tibetan Plateau and/or perhaps central India to the high altitudes of the Himalayas during the last 500 y. While it remains plausible that aeolian dust from sources such as the Arabian Peninsula, Thar Desert, and northern Sahara occasionally travel to the central Himalayan region (41), we suggest that the regional sources have been the prevalent dust provenance for Dasuopu during the last 500 y. Interestingly, during the 19th century, an R² = 0.45 (R² = 0.59 by removing the four largest outliers) between Ca²⁺ and SO₄²⁻ (35) suggests that a contribution from evaporitic minerals of sedimentary origin (gypsum, CaSO₄) may have strongly imprinted the low sulfate background.

The EFs of other typical crustal elements (Ba, Cs, Mg, Ti, U, and V) also remain constant through time (SI Appendix, Table S3), with median decadal values at or near 1.0 (but below 1.2) concomitant with relative increases in their fluxes (40 to 80%) since the beginning of the 19th century (SI Appendix, Table S2). In contrast, EFs of other trace metals (Bi, Cd, Cr, Mo, Ni, Sb, Tl, and Zn) show increases at the end of the 18th century, with median decadal values between 1.7 (Bi) and 5.4 (Zn) (Fig. 3 and SI Appendix, Fig. S7), concomitant with larger increase of their fluxes (70 to 330%).

• Download figure
• Open in new tab
• Download powerpoint

Fig. 3.

Chemical fluxes and crustal EFs (decadal medians) of Cd, Cr, Mo, Ni, Sb, and Zn that show the largest variations in the Dasuopu ice core during the last 500 y. The vertical dotted lines outline the 1810 to 1880 AD period with high snow accumulation, while the gray band spans the period of anthropogenic contributions.

We note that, unlike trace metal concentrations, variations in EF are independent of changes in snow accumulation (and thus fluxes) and need to be explained in terms of variations of the emission sources and/or transport (atmospheric circulation). When combined, these observations suggest that an additional noncrustal fraction of trace metals, such as Bi, Cd, Cr, Mo, Ni, Sb, Tl, and Zn, was transported to high altitude in the central Himalayas since the end of the 18th century (Fig. 3 and SI Appendix, Fig. S7). The amplitude and the peculiar persistence of these metal enrichments over time point to diffused anthropogenic sources as the likely contributor of this noncrustal fraction of trace elements.

To assess the sources of this change in the atmospheric chemistry of the central Himalaya, positive matrix factorization (PMF) was applied to the concentration dataset (SI Appendix, Text S1). Factors 2 and 3 may highlight the distant and regional contributions from the geological background, respectively, because 1) the generally low EF values and limited variability for their characteristic trace metals; 2) the negligible (1%) and high (66%) distribution of arsenic (the proxy of regional crustal background) on these two factors (SI Appendix, Table S4). In contrast, factor 1 is likely linked to anthropogenic activities as it shows a well-defined group of several trace elements that also have notable increases in EF, primarily Cd, Mo, Sb, Zn, and secondarily Cr and Ni (SI Appendix, Table S4). Interestingly, PMF also demonstrates that anthropogenic Pb mass concentration is lower than its crustal contribution by a factor of 4 (SI Appendix, Table S5).

The temporal trend of the anthropic factor 1 (Fig. 4) shows an initial increase at the end of the 18th/beginning of the 19th centuries that parallels European coal production (9) and charcoal deposition from biomass burning in the Northern Hemisphere (14). A further progressive increase of the anthropic factor 1 is observed during the 20th century, peaking in the 1940s to 1950s, and even more remarkably in the 1970s to 1980s. Interestingly, the crustal PMF factors 2 and 3 also peak during the second half of the 20th century (SI Appendix, Fig. S8), indicating an increase in the input of crustal dust to the Dasuopu glacier [see also Al (Fig. 2) and Fe (SI Appendix, Fig. S10) concentrations]. In this case, the recent increase in flux of elements such as Fe, Co, and U (SI Appendix, Fig. S7) may be explained with the augmented deflation of regional dust from expanded soils used for agriculture and pasture (5).

• Download figure
• Open in new tab
• Download powerpoint

Fig. 4.

Hydroclimatology, anthropic factor, biomass burning, and coal production. The annual records, overlain by 5-y median smoothing, of the following: (A) monsoon summer (June to September [JJAS]) precipitation in India (46), (B) November to December North Atlantic Oscillation Index (NAO) (42), and (C) Dasuopu snow accumulation (35). (D) Decadal median of the anthropic factor 1 (Zn, Mo, Cd, Sb) from positive matrix factorization (PMF) of the trace metal concentration dataset of the Dasuopu ice core and (E) charcoal influx z score in the globe and in the Northern Hemisphere (14). (F) Cumulative global and regional coal production since 1800 AD (9). The vertical dotted lines outline the 1810 to 1880 AD period with high snow accumulation, while the gray band spans the period of anthropogenic contributions to trace metal deposition in Dasuopu.

The European Industrial Revolution started a few decades earlier than the beginning of the period marked by change in snow accumulation and deuterium excess observed in the Dasuopu core (1810 to 1880 AD) (Figs. 2 and 4). This hydroclimatic event seems of notable significance because it appears to have modulated the early advection and deposition of atmospheric contaminants to high elevation glaciers in the central Himalayas. This ∼70-y climatic feature observed in the Dasuopu core has been previously described (42). Briefly, the large step increase in snow accumulation was found to be significantly correlated (R = 0.32; 95% significance level) with the November and December Northern Atlantic Oscillation index (NAO) calculated from instrumental values (43) (Fig. 4). It was concluded that the 1810 to 1880 AD increase in snow accumulation on Dasuopu was linked to the intensification of precipitation, probably because of the meridional displacement of the winter westerlies under negative NAO conditions (44). While an increase in deuterium excess can be expected from modern moisture transported by the westerlies to Dasuopu (45), the opposite pronounced decrease observed during the 1810 to 1880 AD period (Fig. 2) is consistent with the contribution of humid air masses from the Tropical Indian Ocean (45) that might have been intercepted by the relocated southern flow of the westerlies at that time. Incorporation of tropical moisture in the western flow would also better explain the remarkable increase in snow accumulation recorded in Dasuopu during the 19th century.

The proposed meridional displacement of the westerlies is supported by the observation of a concomitant extended drought north of the central Himalayas (Puruogangri, central Tibetan plateau) during the 19th century (29). The lack of significant correlation between the Dasuopu snow accumulation and summer monsoon precipitation in Central Northern India (46) (R = 0.05) before 1880 AD further corroborates this interpretation. After 1880 AD, the correlation between snow accumulation and the NAO index becomes insignificant, while the correlation between accumulation and summer monsoon precipitation becomes significant (R = 0.43; 95% significance level), respectively (42). This suggests that the typical seasonal precipitation pattern was established in the central Himalayas after 1880 AD (Fig. 4).

The intensification in the winter snow accumulation during the 1810 to 1880 AD period is paralleled by anomalous patterns in the seasonal deposition of noncrustal trace metals. During the 20th century, EF typically shows low values during the dry winter/spring season and higher levels during the wet summer monsoon (SI Appendix, Fig. S3). This is opposite to the seasonal variations of δ¹⁸O, dust, and trace element concentrations, as typically observed in high-altitude sites that are characterized by a strong seasonality in snow accumulation (47). During the 19th century, despite the marked perseverance of the seasonal patterns of stable isotopes, dust, and crustal element concentrations, the variations of EF of typical noncrustal elements (e.g., Sb, Zn, and Mo) become less obviously seasonal with frequent high values also during winter (SI Appendix, Fig. S4; comparison between the two periods in SI Appendix, Fig. S6). This suggests that the observed increase in EF during the 19th century (Fig. 3) was caused by an additional noncrustal fraction, which was mainly deposited during the anomalously wet winters.

We used modern (1948 to 1992) atmospheric back trajectories to explore potential source areas of the trace metal contaminants in the Dasuopu glacier (SI Appendix, Fig. S13). While 7-d atmospheric summer back trajectories display a frequency field extending to India, the Arabian Sea, and the Middle East, winter back trajectories extend as far as North Africa, Central Europe, and the North Atlantic, suggesting a western origin for the additional metals of noncrustal origin deposited in winter during the 1810 to 1880 AD period. Hereafter, we show that the higher EF and the statistical linkage between Cd, Cr, Mo, Ni, Sb, and Zn (PMF anthropic factor 1), all enriched due to emissions from coal and biomass combustion (18, 48), point to the scenario in which they were transported from widely diffused sources of atmospheric pollution in Western Europe for coal combustion with a possible contribution from forest fires during the 19th century.

European economic data such as coal production and import/export records are available only since the early 19th century (8), during which nearly the entire world’s supply of coal was produced and probably combusted in Western Europe (9) (Fig. 4). It is likely that Western Europe became the most important global emitter of coal ash during the 19th century. Data about coal production in Asia exist only since 1874 AD and show that in India and China it was only 1 to 2% of European production, even by the end of the 19th century (8). As far as is known, there are no data on coal imports in India and China at this time. In any event, these imports were likely to have been negligible because of the very low level or absence of industrialization in these two countries during this period (49, 50), implying negligible regional emissions from coal combustion and other activities such as mining operations in India and China during the 19th century.

At that time, while local emissions from coal combustion are unlikely to have significantly impacted the atmosphere of the central Himalayas, we cannot rule out that trace metals originating from regional and hemispheric-scale biomass burning impacted the chemistry of the Dasuopu glacier. Relatively high EF of Zn (Fig. 3) and Zn mass ratios are consistent with the deposition of a mixture of coal and biomass ashes (SI Appendix, Fig. S9 and Text S3). As far as we know, while there are no specific data for India and China that extend back to the 18th century, it is documented that South Asia underwent an intense change in land use with a 0.6% per year increase of cropland area (net absolute change, 43 Mha in the 18th century), similar to the former USSR (0.7% per year; 33 Mha) and Western Europe (0.3% per year; 19 Mha) (5). These increases may have been correlated to diffuse deforestation by means of biomass burning since the 18th century.

The Dasuopu record after 1880 AD shows that moisture-bearing winter westerlies weakened, trace metal concentrations increased, while anthropogenic trace elements fluxes (Cd, Cr, Mo, Ni, Sb and Zn; Fig. 3) remained at a rather constant level above the preindustrial background. EFs slightly decreased until 1950, although still remaining well above background levels (Fig. 3 and SI Appendix, Fig. S1 and Tables S1–S3). These observations suggest that the increase in concentrations observed in the Dasuopu ice core after 1880 AD could have been due not only to the decrease in snow accumulation rate, but also to a stronger increase in trace metal atmospheric levels, perhaps related to biomass burning emissions due to wildfires linked to the more frequent droughts that occurred in India since the end of the 19th century (51, 52).

In light of the observed trends in trace metal deposition between the 19th century and the first half of the 20th century, we suggest that variations in snow accumulation rate and the sources of moisture at high elevation in the central Himalayas played major roles in determining concentrations, fluxes, and EF levels in the Dasuopu core during this period. Overall, this indicates that, at decadal timescales, the impact of the atmospheric contaminants to the highest Himalayan glaciers can be governed primarily by variations in atmospheric circulation, and secondarily by changes in emission from anthropogenic sources.

No large EF increase is observed in the second half of the 20th century for most of the trace metals, including typical anthropogenic tracers such as Bi, Cd, Cr, Sb, V, and Zn (SI Appendix, Table S3), in part because of the synchronous increase in crustal dust concentration as suggested by PMF factors 2 to 3 and Fe concentrations (SI Appendix, Figs. S8 and S10). The only exception is Pb, the concentration, flux, and EF of which appear to have increased by an order of magnitude, a factor of 2, and 50%, respectively (SI Appendix, Figs. S2, S7, and S11). This is in line with a parallel increase in Pb concentrations determined after 1950 in another firn core from Dasuopu (53), and the observed increase of Pb in other ice core records from the Tibetan Plateau, Himalayas, and Alaska (22, 29, 54⇓–56) that were linked to intensified Pb emissions from gasoline combustion (57). However, the lower-than-expected trace metal levels during this more recent interval (1950 to 1992 AD) in Dasuopu could be also linked to the fact that it was only possible to discretely sample and analyze ∼15% of the recent firn portion of the Dasuopu core covering 1950 to 1992 AD (SI Appendix, Text S4); we cannot entirely rule out the possibility that our analysis did not completely capture the trace metal variability over this selected time period.

In conclusion, this study places onset of anthropogenic contamination of the atmosphere and the pristine snow of the central Himalayas at the end of the 18th/beginning of the 19th centuries, in close concomitance with the start of the European Industrial Revolution, the increasing emissions from coal combustion, and regional/hemispheric biomass burning, likely from deforestation practices. At that time, Dasuopu, and most likely the central Himalayas as a whole, were probably affected by the fallout of fine fly ash transported by anomalous winter westerlies and deposited with the winter snow. This peculiar atmospheric circulation was likely the key factor that allowed the onset of human contamination at very high altitudes in the central Himalayas.